Positive Deviance
(Pascale Sternin)

Knowledge Center

   

Using Indigenous Change Agents. Explanation of Positive Deviance of Pascale and Sternin. ('05)

Contents

  1. Summary
  2. Forum
  3. Best Practices
  4. Expert Tips
  5. Resources
  6. Print

What is the Positive Deviance model? Description

According to Richard Tanner Pascale and Jerry Sternin, there are always positive exceptions to rules concerning business problems. Somehow, a few isolated groups or individuals, operating with the same constraints and resources as everyone else, are functioning better. In the HBR of May 2005, they describe their Positive Deviance method. This holds that managers must actively look for those extraordinarily successful groups and individuals, and bring the isolated success strategies of these "positive deviants" into the mainstream. Best practice Change Management methods are not good at realizing this. That's why Pascale and Sternin suggest to ensure the participation of the members of the community which you want to change in the process of discovery. In this way you can make them the evangelists of their own conversion experience. Also they describe a six-step positive deviance model.
 

Origin of the Positive Deviance approach. History

Pascale and Sternin do not mention Cooperrider in their article. Nor do they explicitly mention Appreciative Inquiry. However it is clear that their approach is based on similar ideas about organizational change. Pascale and Sternin make the following comparison of the Traditional Approach to Change vs. the Positive Deviance Approach to Change:


Traditional Approach to Change

Positive Deviance Approach to Change

Leadership as Path Breaker

Outside-in

Deficit-based

Logic-driven

Vulnerable to Transplant Rejection

Flows from Problem Solving towards Solution Identification

Focused on the Protagonists

Leadership as Inquiry

Inside-out

Asset-based

Learning-driven

Open to Self-Replication

Flows from Solution Identification towards Problem Solving

Focused on Enlarging the Network


Usage of Positive Deviance. Applications

  • See below under strengths and limitations

Six Steps in Positive Deviance. Process

  1. Make the group the guru. Champions and Change Leaders are important, but too often, these individuals generate unconstructive dependence from their teams.
  2. Reframe through facts. Problems must be restated. Rather than starting with an inside-the-box definition. The attention can shift to fertile new grounds and minds are opened to new possibilities.
  3. Make it safe to learn. The positive deviants, the authority figures and the others in the group may all may feel that journeying into terra incognita is a dangerous thing to do. A safe environment must be created that supports innovative ideas.
  4. Make the problem concrete. Otherwise, signal distortion between senders and receivers can quickly cause unwanted effects.
  5. Leverage social proof. The old adage: "Seeing is believing" has special potency when you are dealing with change. Find and communicate examples of solutions that have worked in similar situations.
  6. Confound the immune defense response. Prevent avoidance, resistance and exceptionalism and let the change feel natural. Don't use excessive authority.

Strengths of the Positive Deviance approach. Benefits

  • The method works best for situations where behavioral and attitudinal changes are called for. Where there is no apparent off-the-shelf remedy, and successful coping strategies remain isolated and concealed.
  • Facilitates a role reversal in which experts become learners, teachers become students, and leaders become followers.

Limitations of the Positive Deviance model. Disadvantages

  • Not suited for change initiatives around proven remedies to technical problems. The authors mention Supply Chain Management practices, hardware and software solutions.
  • Not suited for problems that rely on brainpower but that don't require major behavioral adjustments. The authors mention portfolio rebalancing.
  • Requires a role reversal in which experts become learners, teachers become students, and leaders become followers.
  • Creating a safe environment that supports innovative ideas may sometimes not be simple.

Assumptions of the Positive Deviance method. Conditions

  • There are always positive exceptions to rules concerning business problems. Somehow, a few isolated groups or individuals, operating with the same constraints and resources as everyone else, function better.
  • Best practice Change Management methods are not good at bringing successes to the mainstream.
  • If you ensure the participation of people, their avoidance, resistance and exceptionalism will decrease.
  • Time is not the issue.
  • Leaders want to step back and facilitate the process.
  • Positive deviants are willing to share.

Positive Deviance Forum
  Positive Deviance is True but Useless
You allude to it, but I think you should make a more explicit reference to the concept of TBU (True but useless) as it applies to PD....
     
 
  Great exercise (at least annually)
Leaders learning, teachers becoming students - the humility and genuine interest displayed in new ways of thinking, from all levels within the company, helps build morale. "Concrete problems" and "safe to learn" are two of the foundations the proces...
     
 
  Positive Deviance and Horizontal Violence
Has anyone used this method to address horizontal violence / workplace bullying?...
     
 

Positive Deviance Special Interest Group


Special Interest Group

Positive Deviance Education & Events


Find Trainings, Seminars and Events


Best Practices - Positive Deviance Premium

Expert Tips - Positive Deviance Premium
 

What Change Agents Should I Use?

When choosing between internal or external change agents, organizations should consider following advantages and disadvantages of each o...
Usage (application): Change Management, Organizational Change, Turnaround Management
 
 
 

Understanding Why Employee Appreciation is Important

The concept of bases of social power is very important for organizations in the context ...
Usage (application): Acknowledging the Power of Employees
 
 
 

Addressing Concerns Against Change and their Remedies

According to Ken Blanchard in the article “Mastering the Art of Change” (Training Journal, January 2010), it is important for leaders to address the f...
Usage (application): Change Management, Organizational Change, Turnaround Management
 
 
 

Personal Networks of Successful Change Agents

Organizational change is often difficult to achieve because it disturbs the hierarchical structures and the way to accomplish things. For this reason ...
Usage (application): Leading Major and Minor Change Initiatives
 
 
 

Innovating Bottom-up or Top-down

Check out 2 recent articles by professor Deschamps on ...
Usage (application): Corporate Innovation Approaches
 
 
 

I'll never use the term 'Resistance to Change' again

I am working as a change manager in a German IT company. Somebody advised me the other day to read an article about resistance to change by Jeffrey an...
Usage (application): Resistance to Change is a Defensive Attitude...
 
 
 

Key Success Factors when you're Designing your Change Management Program

In their article "Making Change Happen, and Making It Stick" (published in the online edition of strategy+business, December 20, 2010), Ashley Harshak...
Usage (application): Best Practices, Change Management, Organizational Change
 
 
 

The Need to Communicate the REASONS for Change

1072 survey contributors commented on how improve their chances of thriving, by communicating in ways that build trust and engage people. For these co...
Usage (application): Change Management
 
 
 

Assessing the Risks of Change and the Organization’s Capacity for Change

In their book "Transforming Public and Nonprofit Organization – Stewardship for Leading Change", James Edwin Kee and Kathryn E. Newcomer argue that th...
Usage (application): Leading Change
 
 
 

Critical Leadership Skills

In order to tackle all six stages of concern mentioned by Ken Blanchard in the article “Mastering the Art of Change” (Training Journal, January 2010),...
Usage (application): Tackling the Six Stages of Concern
 
 
 

Six Crucial Mind Shifts for Strategy Execution / Implementation

Speculand (2009) suggests six mind shifts that people should consider when they're implementing new strategies in organizations. These are outlined an...
Usage (application): Change Management, Strategic Change, Resistance to CHange, Strategy Implementation
 
 
 

Strategic Change: Why, What, When, Who and How

If we need to change strategically, we need to think about why, what, when, who and how:
- Why do we want to change? - the constraints imp...
Usage (application): Preparing Strategic Change
 
 

Resources - Positive Deviance Premium
 

News

Positive Deviance
     
 

News

Appreciative Inquiry
     
 

Videos

Positive Deviance
     
 

Videos

Appreciative Inquiry
     
 

Presentations

Positive Deviance
     
 

Presentations

Appreciative Inquiry
     
 

More

Positive Deviance
     
 

More

Appreciative Inquiry
     

Compare with the Positive Deviance Approach: Appreciative Inquiry  |  Change Management Iceberg  |  Forget Borrow Learn  |  Kaizen  |  Business Process Reengineering  |  Change Model Beckhard  |  DICE Framework  |  Changing Organization Cultures  |  Action Learning  |  Change Phases  |  Force Field Analysis  |  Core Group Theory  |  MSP  |  Bases of Social Power  |  Planned Behavior  |  Metaplan  |  Team Management Profile


Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |  Communication & Skills  |  Leadership  |  Program & Project Management


More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Special Interest Group Leader

You here


About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us | Privacy | Terms of Service
Copyright 2016 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V14.1 - Last updated: 30-9-2016. All names tm by their owners.