Business Process Reengineering
(BPR)


Fundamentally reconsidering and radically redesigning of organizational processes. Explanation of Business Process Reengineering of Hammer and Champy.

Log in

Business Process ReengineeringThe Business Process Reengineering method (BPR) is described by Hammer and Champy as 'the fundamental reconsideration and the radical redesign of organizational processes, in order to achieve drastic improvement of current performance in cost, services and speed'.


Rather than organizing a firm into functional specialties (like production, accounting, marketing, etc.) and to look at the tasks that each function performs, Hammer and Champy recommend that we should look at complete processes. From materials acquisition, towards production, towards marketing and distribution. One should rebuild the firm into a series of processes.
 

Value creation for the customer is the leading factor for BPR and information technology often plays an important enabling role. Compare: Relationship Marketing

 

Michael Hammer and James Champy

The main proponents of re-engineering were Michael Hammer and James Champy. In a series of books including Reengineering the Corporation, Reengineering Management, and The Agenda, they argue that far too much time is wasted, passing on tasks from one department to another. They claim that it is far more efficient to appoint a team who perform all the tasks in the process.


A five step approach to Business Process Reengineering

Davenport (1992) prescribes a five-step approach to the Business Process Reengineering model:

  1. Develop the business vision and process objectives: The BPR method is driven by a business vision which implies specific business objectives such as cost reduction, time reduction, output quality improvement.
  2. Identify the business processes to be redesigned: most firms use the 'high-impact' approach which focuses on the most important processes or those that conflict most with the business vision. A lesser number of firms use the 'exhaustive approach' that attempts to identify all the processes within an organization and then prioritize them in order of redesign urgency.
  3. Understand and measure the existing processes: to avoid the repeating of old mistakes and to provide a baseline for future improvements. Compare: Scientific Management
  4. Identify IT levers: awareness of IT capabilities can and should influence BPR.
  5. Design and build a prototype of the new process: the actual design should not be viewed as the end of the BPR process. Rather, it should be viewed as a prototype, with successive iterations. The metaphor of prototype aligns the Business Process Reengineering approach with quick delivery of results, and the involvement and satisfaction of customers.

As an additional 6th step of the BPR method, sometimes you find: to adapt the organizational structure, and the governance model, towards the newly designed primary process.


Generic Circumstances that influence whether BPR is advisable

Although it is difficult to give generic advice about this, some factors that can be considered are:

  • Does the competition clearly outperform the company? Compare: Turnaround Management
  • Are there many conflicts in the organization?
  • Is there an extremely high frequency of meetings?
  • Excessive use of non-structured communication? (memos, emails, etc)
  • Is it possible to consider a more continuous approach of gradual, incremental improvements? (see: Kaizen).

Critics of the BPR approach

Reengineering has earned a bad reputation because such projects have often resulted in massive layoffs. In spite of the hype that surrounded the introduction of Business Process Reengineering, partially due to the fact that the authors of Reengineering the Corporation reportedly bought huge numbers of copies to reach the top of the bestseller lists, the method has not entirely lived up to its expectations. The main reasons seem to be that:

  • BPR assumes that the factor that limits organization's performance is the ineffectiveness of its processes. This may or may not always be true. Also BPR offers no means to validate this assumption.
  • BPR assumes the need to start the process of performance improvement with a "clean slate", i.e. totally disregard the status quo.
  • BPR does not provide an effective way to focus the improvement efforts on the organization's constraints. (As done by Goldratt in the Theory of Constraints).
  • Sometimes, or maybe quite often, a gradual and incremental change (such as Kaizen) may be a better approach.
  • BPR is culturally biased towards the US way of thinking. (see: Cultural Dimensions)

BPR compared to Kaizen

When Kaizen is compared with the BPR method is it clear the Kaizen philosophy is more people-oriented, more easy to implement, but requires long-term discipline and provides only a small pace of change. The Business Process Reengineering approach on the other hand is harder, technology-oriented, it enables radical change but it requires considerable change management skills.


Book: Hammer and Champy - Reengineering the Corporation -

Book: Davenport - Process Innovation -


Business Process Reengineering Forum (34) Register  |  Log in  |  Help
BPR - Time Reduction versus Cost
"Doing away the manual processes and bringing in technology and tools to make a process time efficient is one way of doing BPR.
However, technology and tools also come at a certain cost. That's why decision makers are often hesitant to invest in automation without evaluating the business gains. Business dynamics are causing automation to change as well, this is inevitable. Time windows are shrinking, customers are very demanding. They are wiser compared to yesterday. They want value additions and higher value for their money.
To retain, sustain and enhance organization's business/revenues customer base you must have processes with:
- Reduced errors; meaning greater reliability
- Enhanced controls; meaning precision
- More delivery in less time; meaning the processes go faster
- Less physical and mental fatigue; meaning safer working environment

A word of caution. Just because something can be automated that doesn't mean they should be. Automating is not always a good thing to do. Some people may fall into the trap of thinking that if something can be automated, it should be. But that is like someone purchasing a robotic lawn mower, while he enjoys mowing the lawn...
And remember boons and banes (pros and cons) don't travel alone. They always come in pairs."
Deterministic Machines Concept in BPR
"Hi all, could anyone give me a clarification regarding deterministic machines concept in BPR please? How can BPR be viewed in the view of deterministic machine view?"
Developing a Standard Framework for BPR
"After reviewing literature, I think that there exists no standard process of BPR. Every company redesigns its processes in its own way.
I believe different cultures, strategies and organizational structures are the main reasons of adapting so many different methods to BPR.
However, I do believe there is a need for a standard framework which could be applied to any BPR case. We could measure the performance and through continuous improvement enhance the project.
I'm currently doing an MBA research on how to succeed a BPR. To collect your opinions on my ideas, I create a survey. Could you please help me to fill in it in order to understand whether my ideas are right and feasible?
Please click on this link to take the survey. Thank you in advance for your help."
Is BPR Helping ERP or is ERP Helping BPR?
"I am a PhD student and my area is BPR. I just want to know your expert opinion (just general) regarding the relationship of BPR and ERP.
It is a fact that BPR uses technology for efficiency however, I have come across that ERP is doing the same.
So my question is how are these two tools interrelated, and which one is helping the other?
Is BPR used to implement ERP or is ERP helping BPR?"
Cases and Causes of BPR Failure / BPR Disasters
"Hello,
I'm doing research on BPR failure cases. Unfortunately, I can't find any cases to illustrate my research. Could you please tell me where I can find this kind of cases?
Thank you in advance."
Alignment of BPR and IT Solution Approach
"I am conducting research as part of a Masters degree on the combination of business process change methodologies i.e. radical and continuous improvement and IT solution approach such as Commerical Of the Shelf (COTS, package software), Business Process Management Systems (BPMS) / workflow management systems and custom-build used in organisations.
From literature there is evidence that some combinations may not be well suited which may lead to lack of alignment between business service and IT. Also discovered through literature is that there might be factors that influence the use of such combinations e.g. cost, time, standardisation, core processes etc.
For example, the use of BPR and custom development may give a very good alignment because processes with problems are identified, re-engineered and a system custom built to support it. But the cost and time involved in such a project may deter some organisations from going for such option.
The combinations I am looking at are:
1. BPR and COTS
2. BPR and BPMS / workflow systems
3. BPR and custom development.
If you have any experience or knowledge of any of this combinations, please react.
I am looking forward to hear your opinion on this. Thank you."
Faster and more Flexible than BPR - Alternative Approaches?
"Is there any other alternative to BPR? Something that is more flexible, faster and with less work than BPR."
Is BPR Useful for Small Companies (SMEs)?
"Can BPR be used in small and middle size companies as well?"
BPR Works only Top-Down
"I am a BPR envangelist and in my experience BPR is only effective if it starts from the top, i.e. when senior managers accept the challenge to first revamp their mental models of management before they engage in the process. Otherwise all BPR efforts will not work."
Cases of Successful BPR Implementation / BPR Success Stories
"Can you point out companies who were successful in BPR implementation? And what is the success rate of these projects?
I am currently doing my thesis on this topic. Any assistance would be appreciated."
Maintaining the Quality of a BPR Programme
"How can quality be maintained during a BPR inititiative?"
Reward Management During Business Reengineering
"More often than not, Kenyan organizations in need of adapting to changes in the competitive business environment fail to satisfy the needs of the diverse groups of employees within the company. Many employees are exiting, new ones joining in and others face the dilemma of what to do in the wake of the change.
How can a company in the middle of BPR manage it's reward systems to satisfy all groups of employees while at the same time remaining competitive?"
Personal Business Process Reengineering?
"Would anyone help me with one doubt here, can the concept of BPR be implemented in anyone’s personal life to have a radical change? Or is BPR specifically for business need only?"
Business Process Reengineering = People
"In BPR the people are the process and they are central to the success of any innovative change."
BPR Through E-governance Initiatives
"In the public sector field of a government like India, implementing a 100% BPR would be difficult. Because the waste processes & positions identified out of such exercises would be of greater portion and the government itself would be unsure on how to cleanup such wastes. Rather, the focused initiatives to bring many processes under the E-Governance umbrella is a good trade-off to improve the processes (especially done through ppp business model) and at the same time leaving the "government workforce" greatly unaffected."
Business Process Reengineering in Agriculture
"How to start BPR from clean sheet for large and very old agri industry? Any effective guide line? Thank You!"
BPR is Like A Pipeline Through Pour Water
"We know that drinking water comes through a tube for transporting clean water even when it's going through pour water. Without the pipe we do not get clean water. Similarly, to bring change in our country we need to implement BPR. Otherwise, for how many years we keep changing?"
BPR is not an End, but a Means
"BPR is not an end, it is a means to an end."
Misunderstandings around BPR
"Many people misunderstand the concept of BPR as a natural phenomenon or for resisting changes to roll back from its unfavorable impact. Say downsizing. Such people are heard in quoting wrong sayings like "Blood Pressure Raising", but the truth is BPR by itself is not the problem, but the people are who aggravate or mitigate critics of BPR."
Business Process Reengineering and Downsizing
"Why should BPR proceed downsizing?"
Business Process Reengineering can be abused
"I learned that BPR is a helpful tool for developing countries to break their old and unproductive thinking ans system. But I also realized that incompetent leaders can simply abuse it."
ERP and Business Process Reengineering
"Business process reengineering involves radically changing the status quo to fulfil customer's expectation and keep them coming back. This involves change management thinking and implementation of organisational principles. ERP helps in integrating data from functional departments into one single system, thereby giving the whole system one view of same data. I think successful implementation of BPR will not be possible without ERP?"
BPR supported by TQM
"After we implement BPR on the ground we should use TQM as a continuous improvement tool or cal it Kaizen or other tools to maintain the system and satisfy the "moving target" customers needs."
Mental Transformation Required to Implement Business Process Reengineering
"BPR is a tool for making a fundametal ,radical & dramatical change but what is most important is mental transformation required to implement it. I believe if we understand it we can bring a revolutionary chane in our work culture & solve many of our problems in service delivery.
I think we need to design to bring a great satisfaction for our citizens & feel our gaps in service delivery."
BPR needs Positive Thinking
"BPR doesn't need a special management skill, rather it needs positive thinking and a changing way of thinking."
Business Process ReengineeringTypes
"What types of re-engineering processes can be distinguished? Thank you for your input..."
BPR is needed in Ethiopia
"I believe BPR is an important change management tool. It is a radical tool. You can't help or solve all the bureacratic mess created on customers with any other tools - be it Kaizen , TQM, etc.
That is why the Government of Ethiopia at all levels is using this tool to fight bureacracy and bring dramatic improvements in public service delivery."
Required Management Skills
"BPR requires highly skillfull management and deep knowledge of what needs to be done. Is it possible to do BPR with less knowledge of what must be done?"
BPR in agricultural research?
"Is BPR applicable for the agricultural research sector? Is there anyone in the world who can share me the experience how to reengineer the agricultural research system?"
Selective Application
"Authors and consultants like Michael Hammer often present big ideas, because that is the realm they deal with as academics. I think that being a good practitioner means taking the good ideas and applying them, as opposed to applying the concepts wholesale. I would agree with Hammer very much that most organizations waste a lot of time passing on work from one department to another. What can we do to remove these artificial boundaries?"
Costs of BPR - Any ideas?
"Hoping that someone can point to some reference providing info on how much a BPR activity would cost -- some percentage of overhead expenses??"
What Knowledge is Required for BPR?
"The underlying assumption on BPR presented in this article is "task completion through unified team effort". But how is this possible in the practical business world?
There aren't any group of members knowledgeable enough on all business processes. That`s the core reason of existence of organization to achieve more through collective endeavours.
An example: a normal product design & development process requires cross-function participation and activities from:
- MARKETING -- for voice of customer information,
- ENGINEERING -- for product specification development,
- MANUFACTURING -- for existing manufacturing capacity understanding,
- PRODUCTION -- for lead time understanding, and
- QUALITY -- for performance excellence."
Quotes on Business Process Reengineering
"Do you know some deep, famous or funny quotes on Business Process Reengineering? Quotations? Proverbs? Please share them as a reaction to this posting and mention the author. To get started, here's my favorite: 'Reengineering must be fundamental, radical and drastic.' - Michael Hammer & James Champy 1993, American management consultants"
BPR: Lean business processes
"Jeff Hall in Management Services, Winter2006, Vol. 50 Issue 4, encourages the adoption of a lean approach to business process improvement. Lean is about building world class processes that deliver best quality, lowest cost and shortest cycle time through the elimination of waste. With lean being applied to business process, businesses could have a single process team who would be responsible for anything involving the end-to-end ordering-fulfilling-invoicing process thereby reducing waste in the process."


Business Process Reengineering Special Interest Group


Special Interest Group

Business Process Reengineering Education & Events


Find Trainings, Seminars and Events


Compare BPR with:  Outsourcing  |  Change Phases  |  Catastrophe Theory  |  Organic Organization  |  Core Group Theory  |  Appreciative Inquiry  |  Positive Deviance  |  Forget Borrow Learn  |  Planned Behavior  |  Force Field Analysis  |  Kaizen  |  Value Engineering  |  Value Stream Mapping  |  Change Management  |  Six Change Approaches  |  Managing for Value  |  Dimensions of Change  |  Eight Attributes of Management Excellence  |  Five Disciplines  |  Ten Principles of Reinvention  |  Fourteen Points of Management  |  Blue Ocean Strategy  |  Bottom of the Pyramid


Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |  Marketing  |  Strategy  |  Supply Chain & Quality


More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Business Process Reengineering Sponsor
Your firm here
Special Interest Group Leader
Would you like to be our Business Process Reengineering Hammer Champy SIG Leader?





All you need to know about management

12manage for:



Management Smart Card

12manage in:


Copyright 2013 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V12.0 - Last updated: 25-5-2013. All names tm by their owners.