Strategic Stakeholder Management

Knowledge Center

The instrumental approach for stakeholder management. Explanation of Strategic Stakeholder Management of Berman, Wicks, Kotha, Jones ('99) after Freeman. ('84)

The view regarding Strategic Stakeholder Management, described by Berman, Wicks, Kotha, Jones using earlier work of Edward Freeman is an Instrumental Approach. (Academy of Management Journal; Oct99, Vol. 42 Issue 5).

Instrumental approaches towards stakeholder theory hold that:

To maximize shareholder value over an uncertain time frame, managers ought to pay attention to key stakeholder relationships.

Firms have a stake in the behavior of their stakeholders. Prudent management of firms' operating environments, including relationships with their stakeholders, is a part of proper management in general. Therefore good stakeholder management has clear instrumental value for the firms.
 

A fundamental assumption of this type of model is that the ultimate objective of corporate decisions is marketplace success. Firms view their stakeholders as part of an environment that must be managed in order to assure revenues, profits, and ultimately, to provide returns to shareholders. Attention to stakeholder issues may help a firm avoid decisions that might prompt stakeholders to undercut or thwart its objectives. This possibility arises because stakeholders can control resources that can facilitate or enhance the implementation of corporate decisions (Pfeifer & Salancik, 1978); in short, Stakeholder Management is a means to reach an end; something what you have to do so that you can achieve something else. The end, or the ultimate result, is generally not the welfare of stakeholders. Instead, the firm's goal is the advancement of the interests of only one stakeholder group: its shareholders. Employing the terminology used by Donaldson and Preston (1995) and Quinn and Jones (1995), we see the concern of the firm for stakeholder relationships as instrumental and contingent on the value of those relationships to corporate financial success. Quinn and Jones stated: "Instrumental [strategic] ethics enters the picture as an addendum to the rule of wealth maximization for the manager-agent to follow" (1995: 25).

In this formulation, stakeholder management is part of a company's strategy but in no way drives that strategy. Implicit in this perspective is the assumption that modes of dealing with stakeholders that prove upon adoption to be unproductive will be discontinued, as will those that involve resources that are no longer needed. The concerns of stakeholders only enter a firm's decision-making processes if they have strategic value for the firm.

Two variants of the Strategic Stakeholder Management approach are the direct effects model and the moderation model. In the direct effects model, the attitudes and the actions of managers toward stakeholders (their stakeholder orientation) are perceived as having a direct effect on firm financial performance, independent of the corporate strategy. In the moderation model, the managerial orientation toward stakeholders does impact the corporate strategy by moderating the relationship between strategy and financial performance.

Special Interest Group - Strategic Stakeholder Management Special Interest Group (221 members)

Forum - Strategic Stakeholder Management   In this forum you will find recent interesting discussions.   Stakeholder Definition? (6 reactions) I need a comprehensive definition of a Stakeholder. Who can ...         Treating Patients as Strategic Stakeholders After working for more than 4 years and on 4 different healt...           Stakeholders Involvement in the Strategic Change Management Process in Public Organizations (2 reactions) I would really appreciate to receive some positive input on ...           Include Stakeholder Management in Strategy (2 reactions) I would appreciate to receive some views to the position tha...           Stakeholders Management and Partnering I need some help to explore the relations between Stakeholde...           Involving Stakeholders in the Introduction of Change What are the systems to involve apporariate stakeholder in t...

Best Practices - Strategic Stakeholder Management Here you will find the most valuable discussions from the past.

Expert Tips - Strategic Stakeholder Management Here you will find high-quality advice from experts.   Stakeholder Capitalism (Freeman) Stakeholder Management...       4 Levers to Pursue a Dual Corporate Purpose CSR, Impact on Society, Balancing Financial and Social Goals, Dual Purpose...       CEOs Time Spent per Stakeholder / Constituency CEO Coaching, CEO Time Management, Stakeholder Management...       How to Effectively Conduct a Stakeholders Meeting? Stakeholder Meetings, Best Practices...       The Role of the CEO in Strategic Change Initiation Communicating Strategic Change...       The Maturity Stages of Corporate Responsibility Organizational Development, Corporate Responsibility Maturity...

Resources - Strategic Stakeholder Management Here you will find powerpoint presentations, micro-learning videos and further information sources. The Purpose of Business: Stockholder versus Stakeholder Theories Stakeholder Analysis; Stakeholder Commitment...   Strategy, Society and CSR CSR Strategy, Competitive Advantage, Strategic Corporate Social Responsibility, Strategy and Society...   The Dawn of Conscious Capitalism Conscious Capitalism, Value-driven Consumer, Socially Responsible Investing, Corporate Responsibility...   CSR Implementation and Communication Model (Schmeltz) CSR Communication, CSR Implementation, CSR Strategy, Corporate Identity, Corporate Values, CSR Stages,...   Introduction to Stakeholder Management Introduction to Stakeholder Management...   Strategic Stakeholder Management Diagram Strategic Stakeholder Management...   Stephen Covey on the Speed of Trust Corporate Strategy, Global Economy, Banking System, Leadership Development, Stakeholder Management...     News about Strategic Stakeholder         News about Instrumental Stakeholders         Videos about Strategic Stakeholder         Videos about Instrumental Stakeholders         Presentations about Strategic Stakeholder         Presentations about Instrumental Stakeholders         Books about Strategic Stakeholder         Books about Instrumental Stakeholders         More about Strategic Stakeholder         More about Instrumental Stakeholders

Compare with Strategic Stakeholder Management: Intrinsic Stakeholder Commitment  |  Normative Approach of Stakeholder Theory  |  Shareholder Value Perspective  |  Stakeholder Value Perspective  |  Stakeholder Analysis  |  Stakeholder Mapping  |  Value Based Management  |  Strategic Intent  |  Moral Purpose

Return to Management Hub: Ethics & Responsibility  |  Human Resources  |  Leadership  |  Strategy

More Management Methods, Models and Theory