Strategic Risk Management
(Slywotzky Drzik)

Knowledge Center

What is Strategic Risk Management? Description

Although Adrian J. Slywotzky and John Drzik of Mercer did not conceive the terminology Strategic Risk Management (SRM), they deserve credit for their excellent description of it in an article in the Harvard Business Review of April 2005. SRM is a technique that can be used for devising and deploying a systematic approach for managing strategic risk, the array of external events and trends that can devastate a company's growth trajectory and shareholder value.

The authors distinguish 7 Classes of Strategic Risk, with underlying subcategories. (some typical countermeasures in italic):

1. Industry
   • Margin Squeeze - shift the compete / collaboration ratio
   • Rising R&D / capital expenditure costs
   • Overcapacity
   • Commoditization
   • Deregulation
   • Increased power among suppliers
   • Extreme business-cycle volatility
2. Technology
   • Shift in technology - double bet
   • Patent expiration
   • Process becomes obsolete
3. Brand
   • Erosion - redefine the scope of brand investment, reallocate your brand investment
   • Collapse
4. Competitor
   • Emerging global rivals
   • Gradual market-share gainer
   • One-of-a-kind competitor - create a new, non overlapping business design
5. Customer
   • Customer priority shift - create and analyze proprietary information, conduct quick and cheap market experiments
   • Increasing customer power
   • Over-reliance on a few customers
6. Project - smart sequencing, developing excess options, employing the stepping-stone method
   • R&D failure
   • IT failure
   • Business development failure
   • Merger or acquisition failure
7. Stagnation
   • Flat or declining volume - generate "demand innovation"
   • Volume up, price down
   • Weak pipeline

Note: Certain financial-, operational-, and hazardous risks can potentially also be of strategic significance.

Origin of Strategic Risk Management. History

The first notion we could find of the term "Strategic Risk Management" is in a paper called "A framework for integrated risk management in international business", By: Miller, Kent D., Journal of International Business Studies, 00472506, 1992, Vol. 23, Issue 2.

Miller describes five "generic" responses to strategic environmental uncertainties, being avoidance, control, cooperation, imitation, and flexibility:

1. Uncertainty avoidance occurs when management considers the risk associated with operating in a given product or geographic market to be unacceptable. For a firm already active in a highly uncertain market, uncertainty avoidance involves exiting, through divesting the specialized assets committed to serving the market. For firms not yet participating in a market, uncertainty avoidance implies postponement of market entry until the industry uncertainties decrease to acceptable levels.
2. Firms may seek to control important environmental contingencies to reduce uncertainties. Managers are here predisposed to trying to control uncertain variables rather than passively treat the uncertainties as constraints within which they must operate. Examples of control strategies include:
   • political activities (e.g., lobbying for or against laws, regulations, or trade restraints),
   • gaining market power, and
   • undertaking strategic moves that threaten competitors into more predictable (and advantageous) behavior patterns.
3. Cooperative responses are different from control responses, because they involve multilateral agreements, rather than unilateral control, as the means for achieving uncertainty reduction. Uncertainty management through coordination is resulting in increased behavioral interdependence and in a reduction in the autonomy of the coordinating organizations. Cooperative strategies for reducing uncertainty include:
   • long-term contractual agreements with suppliers or buyers,
   • voluntary restraint of competition,
   • alliances or joint ventures,
   • franchising agreements,
   • technology licensing agreements, and
   • participation in consortia.
4. Firms may resort to imitation of rival organizations' strategies to cope with uncertainty. This behavior can result in coordination among industry rivals. But the basis of this coordination is clearly distinct from that under control or cooperation strategies. In this case, no direct control or cooperative mechanism is used. Rather, an industry leader is able to predict the response of rivals because their responses are merely lagged imitations of its own strategic moves. Imitation strategies ("follow-the-leader-behavior") involve pricing and product strategies that follow those of an industry leader.
   Imitation of product and process technologies may be a viable low-cost strategy in some industries [Mansfield, Schwartz & Wagner 1981]. But uncertainty about the underlying technology of competing firms may preclude such a strategy [Lippman & Rumelt 1982].
5. A fifth general category of strategic responses to environmental uncertainties involves managerial moves to increase organizational flexibility. Unlike control and cooperation strategies which attempt to increase the predictability of important environmental contingencies, flexibility responses increase internal responsiveness. The predictability of external factors is left unchanged. The most widely cited example of flexibility in the strategy literature is product or geographic market diversification. Diversification reduces company risk through involvement in various product lines and/or geographic markets with returns that are less than perfectly correlated.

Usage of Strategic Risk Management. Applications

• Strategic Planning
• Risk Mitigation and Prevention
• Crisis Management
• Capital Allocation
• Capital Structure

Steps in the Strategic Risk Management Process

1. Identify and assess risks (severity, probability, timing, likelihood over time).
2. Map risks (create a strategic risk map).
3. Quantify risks (in a common measurement currency - i.e. economic capital at risk, market value at risk).
4. Identify potential positive consequences of risks (if company turns the risk into an opportunity).
5. Develop risk mitigation action plans (by risk teams).
6. Adjust capital decisions (capital allocation and capital structure).

Strengths of Strategic Risk Management. Benefits

• Preparation for a major risk enables mitigation of that risk and makes sense to protect company stability.
• If you prepare better for risks than your competitors, who simply manage risks in the "old" way, you have a source of competitive advantage.
• Tool for thinking systematically about the future and identifying opportunities.
• You can turn strategic threats into growth opportunities. Moving from the defense into the offense.
• Probably the benefits of SRM outweigh those of other, less strategic forms of managing risk.
• Avoiding insolvency risks or earnings volatility.
• If you can reduce your GAAP/IAS volatility, this may mean you will have a better standing in the analyst community.
• You can better utilize capital and reduce its costs.
• Organize systems and processes that increase the Risk-Adjusted Return on Capital of the firm.
• Protect corporate reputation.
• Helps companies to fend off additional regulatory and legislative assaults on how they run their businesses.
• Helps corporate executives to defend themselves against legal lawsuits of the sort that have been filed against former Enron, Tyco and WorldCom executives.

Limitations of Strategic Risk Management. Disadvantages

• Strategic risks are just one of four categories of risks (Others are: financial-, hazard, and operational risk).
• Certain risks may occur and cause irreparable damage despite anticipation and preparation ("Acts of God").
• No company can anticipate all risk events.
• SRM is not a box-checking exercise: there are substantial costs and efforts involved to SRM.
• A major potential issue in accomplishing progress with regards to SRM is that in light of Sarbanes-Oxley and other post-Enron developments, companies may likely view SRM as simply another regulation being imposed on them rather than new "ground rules" that, if followed enthusiastically, have the potential to provide global competitive advantage and enhance shareholder value.

Assumptions of Strategic Risk Management. Conditions

• It is possible to prepare for major future risks.
• Preparing is useful.
• It is possible to turn risks into opportunities.

Forum - Strategic Risk Management   Discussions about Strategic Risk Management.   Current Economic Conditions and Strategic Risk Management How can we explain the current recession in the light of SRM? Which of above categories does this period fit into? Does (...)           Enterprise Risk Management versus Strategic Risk Management These days the importance of managing all risks together has been recognized by organizations. Any risk management proce (...)           SRM Experiences and Results The article deeply describes the academic values of the term Strategic Risk Management. Who can share some experiences a (...)           Strategic Expenditures (StratEx) A useful recommendation by Robert Kaplan and David Norton is to create a new expenditure category to protect strategic i (...)           How to Manage Unavoidable Risk Truly unavoidable risk can be managed only in a sense, the risk themselves are unavoidable. Therefore to manage them you (...)           Strategic Risk Management in Agri Business Can anybody explain how SRM can be used in agribusiness sector i.e. how to mitigate the risk? (...)           Involve SRM when making Strategic Decisions Many companies do not consider the strategic risk involved when making strategic decisions. It thus becomes an issue whe (...)           An 8th Class of Strategic Risk? I would like to suggest "People" (human resources) as another class of strategic risk (management). People are vital: - (...)         Classes of Political Risk. Types There turn out to be no less than 10 types of political risk. I stumbled on this useful list and thought I'd share it si (...)           ISO 31000 on Risk Management The ISO have introduced a standard, ISO 31000 on risk management. Excellent, especially with the accompanying Guide 73 w (...)           Strategies for Investment Risk Mitigation What are strategies for risk mitigation? (...)           Opportunism in Risk Management How many times have we come across situations where middle management is deeply involved in risk avoidance but people on (...)           Risk Management for Beginners How to introduce risk management for those who are not aware of derivative markets (novice)? The reason for asking this (...)           Go find Risks... Embracing Risks Go find risks... don't be afraid of risks... Without risks there is no profit. So get a brave heart and navigate. (...)           SRM for Central Banks? How can SRM be applied to central banks in southern africa? (...)

Expert Tips - Strategic Risk Management Here you will find advices by experts.   Risk Universe Model Project Risk Reporting (...)       The Levels of Risk Risk Hierarchy (...)       E&Y Risk Radar Monitoring, Weighting and Prioritization of Risks (...)       Pitfalls of Traditional Risk Analysis Risk Management, Crisis Management (...)       Critical Success Factors of RM Improve your RM process (...)       Strategic versus Financial Risk Management Comparison of Typical Activities (...)       How to Design Experiments to Support Decision-making on Strategic Innovations Strategic Innovation, Strategic Decision-making, Strategic Experimenting, Experiments, Strategic Testing, Innovation Tes (...)       How to Link Risk Management and Strategy? Strategic Risk Management, Best Practices (...)       Align Strategy and Risk Management Performance-Aligned Risk Management (...)       Taking Risk Management from Control and Compliance into a Competitive Advantage Strategic Risk Management (...)       Why Society is More Risky than Before Understanding New Risk Categories, Risk Management (...)       Align Your Risk Management Strategy with Investors' View on Risk Strategic Risk Management, Transparant Risk Management (...)       Critical Components of Risk Management Platform Risk Management (...)

Resources - Strategic Risk Management Here you find powerpoint presentations, micro-learning videos and further information sources. Scenario Planning and Risk Management in Uncertain Business Enviroment Scenario Planning, Risk Management, Strategic Uncertainty (...)   Enterprise Risk Management and Integrated Risk Management Enterprise Risk Management, Risk Management (...)   The Risk Management Process in Steps Risk Management Steps, Strategic Risk Management, Process of Risk Management (...)   Steps in Strategic Risk Management Process Risk Management, Decision-making (...)   Example Risk Register Risk Management (...)   How to Apply the COSO Enterprise Risk Management Integrated Framework Enterprise Risk Management, COSO ERM Framework (...)   Managing Risks Through Internal Controls Internal Controls, Risk Management (...)   The Six Basic Questions of Risk Management: Introduction to Risk Management Initial Understanding of Risk Management, Risk Management Introduction (...)   The Importance of Reputational Risk and Managing it Reputation Management, Risk Management (...)   Business Continuity Management and Disaster Recovery Management Business Continuity Planning, Disaster Recovery Planning, Crisis Management, Organizational Absorption (...)   Using Big Data for Competitive Advantage Customer Analysis, Data Management (...)

Compare with Slywotzky's and Drzik's Strategic Risk Management: Scenario Planning  |  RAROC  |  Game Theory  |  Plausibility Theory  |  PEST Analysis  |  Crisis Management  |  Real Options  |  CAPM  |  Turnaround Management

Return to Management Hub: Decision-making & Valuation  |  Finance & Investing  |  Knowledge & Intangibles  |  Strategy

More Management Methods, Models and Theory