Seven Surprises for New CEOs
(Michael Porter)

Knowledge Center

Summary, forum, best practices, expert tips and information sources.

112 items • 331.186 visits


The Seven Surprises for New CEOs were described for the first time in the HBR of October 2004 in an article regarding CEO Leadership by Michael Porter, Jay Lorsch and Nitin Nohria.

As a newly appointed CEO, one may think to finally have the power to set strategy. The authority to make things happen, and full access to the finer points of your business. But if you expect that this job is so simple, you'd better wake up now. You bear full responsibility for your company's well-being. But you are a few steps away from many important business factors. You have more power than anybody in the corporation, but you need to use it with extreme caution.

Porter, Lorsch and Nohria have discovered that nothing - not even leading a large business within the company - fully prepares a person to be the chief executive.

The seven most common SURPRISES for new CEOs:

  1. You can't run the company. The sheer volume and intensity of external demands take many by surprise. Almost every new chief executive struggles to manage the time drain of attending to shareholders, analysts, board members, industry groups, politicians, and other constituencies.
  2. Giving orders is very costly. No proposal should reach the CEO for final approval, unless he can ratify it with enthusiasm. Before then, everyone working on the matter should have raised and resolved any potential deal breakers. The CEO should be brought into the discussion only at strategically significant moments to give feedback and support.
  3. It is hard to know what is really going on. Certainly, CEOs are flooded with information, but reliable information is surprisingly scarce. All information coming to the top of the enterprise is filtered, sometimes with good intentions, sometimes with not such good intentions.
  4. You are always sending a message. The words and actions of a CEO, however small or said casually, are instantly spread and amplified, scrutinized, interpreted and sometimes drastically misinterpreted. Compare: Charismatic Leadership
  5. You are not the boss. Although the CEO may sit on the top of the management hierarchy, he still reports to the board of directors. Ultimately, the board is in charge. Not the CEO.
  6. Pleasing shareholders is not the goal. CEOs must recognize that, ultimately, it is only long-term value creation that is important. Today's growth expectations or even the stock price are not so relevant. Compare: Moral Purpose
  7. You are still only human. CEO should recognize that he needs connections to the world outside his organization, at home and in the community. In order to avoid that he is completely consumed by his corporate life.

These Seven Surprises for new CEOs carry some important lessons:

  • First, as a new CEO you must learn to manage organizational context rather than focus on daily operations.
  • Second, you must recognize that your position does not confer the right to lead, nor your position guarantees the loyalty of the organization.
  • Finally, you must remember that you are subject to a range of limitations, even though others might treat you as if you were omnipotent.

Special Interest Group

Seven Surprises for New CEOs Special Interest Group.

Special Interest Group (36 members)


Forum discussions about the Seven Surprises for New CEOs. Below you can ask a question about this topic, share your experiences, report a new development, or explain something.

Start a new topic about Seven Surprises for New CEOs


Even CEOs Need Time to Learn...
Anyone new to a position is a learner; most CEOs will not readily appreciate that.
To be the top boss is a cherished ambition. On attaining it, one invariably presses the "undo' switch to assert ...
Undercutting CEO Power
In Fortune (Europe, March 12, 2007, no. 4) Geoff Colvin mentions some new rules that decrease the authority of existing (US) CEOs in favor of the shareholders: 1. From 1993, institutional shareholders...
Don't underestimate the emotional and positional power a CEO has
The emotional and positional power a CEO exercises is drastically underestimated by new CEOs. Serious attention to words and potential meanings, physical interactions and worst possible presumptions o...
Even CEOs Need Support from their Team
CEOs need to know that the team they are leading is very important if they want be successful.
The support from the team is crucial and one goal should be to win that support. It is easy and als...
Alternate Meanings of CEO: Chief Excitement Officer
Besides the standard
- Chief Executive Officer
and the already mentioned in this forum:
- Chief Enabling Officer / Chief Empowerment Officer
we can also see CEO as:
- Chief Ex...
🔥 NEW The Importance of Empathy, Gratitude and Generosity for (New) Leaders
New leaders encounter challenges as they move up the ladder, a disturbing one of which is so called the 'power paradox'. When people start to feel powerful or enjoy a position of privilege, the select...
Being a Chief Executive Officer (CEO) is Easy
The CEO can choose between authority or knowledge. Trusting the team is a key for success. A CEO should focus only on strategic things and delegate other functions to subordinates. A CEO can create th...
On #6: Shareholder Pleasing is not the Goal
Well I think Porter is missing an important point when he says pleasing shareholders is not a goal. I am not a professor on a university but my school is 30 years practice in multinationals. If a CEO ...
7 More CEO Surprises
1. He can be the loneliest person in the middle of nowhere.
2. Confidentiality on certain issues makes him lonelier still.
3. Figuring out the real enemies, within and without.
4. 90% o...
CEO: the Strategist of Business
Despite of surprising himself with a lot of challenges, the CEO will be accountable for an effective strategy applied with agility and intelligence to the business.
That means... he is the comman...
Combine Top Down with Bottom Up Thinking
I guess sometimes man must change his view to the company; not always looking and thinking from the top down, but sometimes explore a bottom up approach as well. This allows one to find out more thing...
Assimilating the Right Type of Information
A CEO is usually flooded with information which can become confusing. What the CEO ought to do is to place all relevant information on the yardstick of the wider vision of the company.
Once the ...
The Top Leader's View: A Leadership Labyrinth
Working on my dissertation in Leadership raised an interesting series of questions for me.
1. Is there still a leadership ceiling once you reached the top leadership position?
2. If we're as...
CEO's Dilemma: Infinite Business Possibilities in a Finite Company!
In an organizations, there are many choices to make about the dimensions of strategy, management, intelligence, synergy and innovation to achieve business success.
Disagreements in the organizati...
On #3: It's Hard to Know what is Really Going On
What are the most effective ways for a CEO to determine if the information she/he is getting is accurate?...
On #7: Even a CEO is Still Only Human
I gained a better understanding upon review of the seven most common surprises for new CEO's. I also favor the idea of servant leadership, which the seven most common surprises for new CEO's prompted ...
CEO is a Facilitator and Needs Followers
A new CEO must share his/her vision to the organization in order to attract followers. In the whole process, the CEO must also be ready to be led by the followers.
Carrying out a stakeholder anal...
Surprises to a CEO: You Need to Deal with Undercurrents
As a ship sails along the sea, there are undercurrents that tend to limit speed and change direction. The captain of the ship (CEO) has to have knowledge, plans and strategies to undercut these counte...

Best Practices

The best, top-rated topics about the Seven Surprises for New CEOs. Here you will find the most valuable ideas and practical suggestions.

Chief Enabling Officer
In a predominantly knowledge-based organization, it would be more productive for a CEO to see himself as a 'Chief Enabling Officer', and adopt the philosophy of the book "Employees first, customers se...

Expert Tips

Advanced insights about the Seven Surprises for New CEOs. Here you will find professional advices by experts.

Leadership is a Momentum Game..

What Early Actions are Most Important for Leaders?
Leadership development consultant Michael D. Watkins writes in HBR June 2009 (p 34-35) that leadership is a momentum gam...

Myths on REACHING the top

What Experiences, Qualifications and Characteristics are Needed to Reach the Top?
I'd like to contribute a summary of an article by HRM Professor Monika Hamori of Instituto de Empresa Business School. H...

Categeories of CEO's

Leadership Styles, CEO Types
In their book "The Secrets of CEOs", Steve Tappin and Andrew Cave identified that top-quartile CEOs fall into five disti...

Five Leadership Development Ideas

Leadership Development, Management Development, Coaching, Mentoring
Although years of research and analysis by biographers, historians, and scholars have produced an enormous library of bo...

Pursuing a Dual Corporate Purpose

CSR, Impact on Society, Balancing Financial and Social Goals, Dual Purpose
These is a slow but steadily increasing trend for corporations to diminish their single-minded pursuit of shareholder va...

Mintzberg: 7 Myths on Management

Management Development, Leadership Development, Managers versus Leaders, MBA
Prof. Henry Mintzberg refutes 7 myths on leadership and management: ORCHESTRA CONDUCTOR: One myth about management is t...

Leadership Best Practices

Leadership Development, Leadership Tips
- The best leaders always know how to involve others in making decisions: You will get a better range of ideas and they ...

Identify and Develop Leadership Abilities

Leadership Development, Management Development, Coaching, Mentoring
Covey's 4 Roles of Leadership® helps managers to identify and develop 4 important abilities of 'true' leaders: 1. Model...

Founder-CEO firms

HR, FInance
New CEO's have a disadvantage anyway: American (!) companies led by a founder-CEO are reported to do better in the capit...

Effective Top Management Teams in Multinationals. Requirements and Characteristics

Board of Directors, Leadership Teams, Multinationals, Top Team Management
There are three requirements for effective top team management in large, multinational enterprises: 1. Clear charter an...

LEADER: Best Practices for Effective Leadership Behavior

Leadership Behavior, Leadership Effectiveness, Leadership Style
Following six short behavioral tips can help you to enhance your leadership efficiency: 1. L - LISTENING: Actively list...

How Should CEOs Manage and Communicate the Main Messages?

Strategic Communication, Leader Skills, Communication Skills, Leader Perspective
Inspiring the organisation to create a better future is arguably the ultimate mission of any leader or CEO. That's why a...

CEOs Time Spent per Stakeholder / Constituency

CEO Coaching, CEO Time Management, Stakeholder Management
Research by Porter, Nohria and Higgins among 27 CEOs revealed the following interesting data on with whom they spend the...

How Long Should a CEO Remain in the Job?

CEO Performance, CEO Life Cycle, CEO Tenure, CEO and Board Relation
What is the best amount of years for a CEO to remain in his or her job? Sometimes you hear people mentioning 7 years or ...

Reasons and Remedies to Dissonance in Leaders

Primal Leadership, Emotional Intelligence, Stress, Cognitive Dissonance, Resonance
In today’s constantly changing, challenging and demanding environment, it is hard for leaders to remain effective and re...

The Importance of Culture in Organizational Performance

Organizational Culture, Corporate Culture, Employee Behavior, Organizational Performance
John Connolly, former CEO of Deloitte UK, argues that one of the most critical determinants of organizational performanc...
Information Sources

Various sources of information regarding the Seven Surprises for New CEOs. Here you will find powerpoints, videos, news, etc. to use in your own lectures and workshops.

CEO's influence on Performance

CEO, Firm performance
The extent to which CEOs influence firm performance is fundamental to scholarly understanding of how organizations work;...

Power and Politics in Organizations

Power Relations, Bases of Power, Political Behavior, Politics, Political Tactics, Organizational Politics
This presentation covers the topic of politics in organization, especially focusing on power issues. The presentation in...

The Fatal Coaching Mistake by Managers

Coaching, Mentoring, Management, Leadership
Managers and executives often don't realize how much influence they have over their staff, by just being their superior...

Video Introduction to Leadership

First Understanding of Leadership, Trainings, Workshops
Quick visual intro to the subject of leadership by showing short impressions of: harmony, driving performance, followin...

CEO Succession Planning

Succession Planning
Presentation about CEO Succession Planning thereby making a difference between compliance-based and operational successi...

Steven Covey on his 8 Habits of Effective People / Managers / Leaders

Understanding the 8 Habits of Covey. Leadership Development, Management Development, Coaching, Mentoring
In this video Steven Covey explains his 7 habits plus the 8th habit he added later: 1. Be proactive 2. Begin with the ...

Research Links

Jump to further research sources regarding the Seven Surprises for New CEOs.













Compare with the Seven Surprises for New CEOs:  Seven Habits (Covey)  |  Servant-Leadership  |  Level 5 Leadership  |  EPIC ADVISERS  |  Leadership Pipeline  |  Coaching  |  Mentoring  |  Value Based Management  |  Core Group Theory  |  Strategic Stakeholder Management  |  SMART  |  Path-Goal  |  Leadership Continuum  |  Situational Leadership  |  Theory X Theory Y  |  4 Dimensions of Relational Work  |  Leadership Styles  |  Strategic Intent  |  Results-Based Leadership

Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |  Communication & Skills  |  Leadership  |  Strategy & Innovation

More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Special Interest Group

Do you know a lot about the Seven Surprises for New CEOs? Become our SIG Leader and gain worldwide recognition as an expert.

About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2023 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V16.1 - Last updated: 26-3-2023. All names ™ of their owners.