Four Trajectories of Industry Change

Knowledge Center


How industries change. Explanation of Trajectories of Industry Change of Anita M. McGahan. (2004)


  1. Summary
  2. Forum
  3. Best Practices
  4. Expert Tips
  5. Resources
  6. Print

The Four Trajectories of Industry Change is a model to describe how industries change. The author of the model is Anita M. McGahan, Professor of Management in Boston. She published the model for the first time in the HBR of October 2004.

According to McGahan you can't make intelligent investments within your organization unless you understand how your whole industry is changing. The need to understand change in your industry may seem obvious, but such knowledge is not always easy to collect. Companies sometimes miss or misinterpret clues and arrive at false conclusions often.

Why industries evolve

Research by McGahan suggests that industries evolve as a result of two types of threats of obsolescence:

  • A threat to core activities of the industry. A threat to the recurring activities of companies, which historically generated profits for the industry.
  • A threat to the core assets of the industry. A threat to the durable resources, including intangibles such as knowledge and brand capital, that have historically made the organization efficient at performing core activities.

How industries change

Resulting out of a combination of the above two types of threats, industries change along one of Four Trajectories of Industry Change:

  1. Radically. When core assets and core activities are both threatened with obsolescence. Advice:
    • Perform a balancing act. Aggressively pursuing profits in the short term while avoiding investments that could later prevent you from decreasing your commitments, PLUS:
    • Assess how quickly your core assets are depreciating. And determine the segments in which you can protect your competitive position from those in which your position will erode quickly.
  2. Progressive. When neither core assets nor core activities are jeopardized. Advice:
    • Develop a system of interrelated activities that are defensible because of their compounding effects on profits, not because they are hard to understand or replicate; be the biggest.
  3. Creative. When core assets are under threat but core activities are stable. Advice:
    • Assess how quickly your core assets are depreciating. And determine the segments in which you can protect your competitive position from those in which your position will erode quickly.
  4. Intermediating. When core activities are threatened while core assets retain their capacity to create value. Advice:
    • Perform a balancing act. Aggressively pursuing profits in the near term while avoiding investments that could later prevent you from decreasing your commitments.

The Trajectories of Industry Change typically unfold themselves over decades. Fighting the industry change is almost always too costly to be worthwhile. Rather organizations should reconfigure themselves for lower revenue growth and develop the ability to remove activities and resources out of the business. Systematically analyzing the business environment is not easy, but the payoff is great: better strategic decision-making for your company.

Trajectories of Industry Change Forum
  Consolidation of Industry
What does it mean when an industry is consolidating, not just a separate company but a whole industry?...
  Managing Change is an Art
Managing the vagaries of change can only be aimed towards minimising the deviation from the intended path of success. This is because change itself sets off competitive response that aims to neutralise if not delay the corrective measures that are im...
  Management Mega Trends
In my personal point of view, the future in the business management world is very difficult to predict, but co-innovation, core competences, blue ocean strategy, mega fusions, stakeholders, and social responsibility are the most important mega trends...

Trajectories of Industry Change Special Interest Group

Special Interest Group

Trajectories of Industry Change Education & Events

Find Trainings, Seminars and Events

Best Practices - Trajectories of Industry Change Premium

Expert Tips - Trajectories of Industry Change Premium

Innovation Pitfalls

Harvard Professor R. Moss Kanter describes 4 common innovation mistakes and corresponding remedies (HBR Nov 2006):
Usage (application): Avoiding Innovation Traps

Industry’s Driving Forces

Many events can affect an industry powerfully enough to qualify as driving forces. Some are unique and specific to a particular industry, but most ...
Usage (application): Organizational Change

Pitfalls and Obstacles in Product Development Strategy

Although product development can be an important growth strategy, it is necessary to keep in mind that several factors tend to hinder this strategy: Usage (application): Product Development, Product Portfolio Management

How to Become a Self-tuning Enterprise: Advanced Experimenters

In an HBR article of June 2015, Reeves, Zeng and Venjara argue there's a new way to apply algorithmic principles that enables organizations to constan...
Usage (application): Organizational Agility, Strategic Agility, Real Options, Emergent Strategy

How Can Incumbents Respond to Disruptors?

In recent years, the challenges to incumbent majors across industries have come mainly from low-cost competitors and from dotcoms (e.g. British Airwa...
Usage (application): 5 Strategic Options in Reaction to Disruptors

How to Identify the Trajectory of an Industry?

In order to identify the evolutionary trajectory of an industry, McGahan suggests a focused and systematic analysis:
1. The first step is to defi...
Usage (application): Predicting Industry Change

Classes of Innovation | Sources of Innovation

Innovation can be triggered or enabled by two broad classes:
  1. KNOWLEDGE PUSH: Innovation triggered...
    Usage (application): Innovation, Creativity, Organizational Innovativeness, Lateral Thinking, Out of the Box Thinking, Blue Ocean Strategy

Innovating by Reconsidering Value Delivery

When innovating their business model, companies need to reconsider their value proposition from all perspectives. One of the perspectives is how compa...
Usage (application): Fundamental Innovation

In Which Direction Should we Grow our Portfolio?

According to Professor Aneel G. Karnani in 'Mastering Strategy', there's no standard way to gain market value for all businesses. An answer that works...
Usage (application): Portfolio Strategy, Innovation Strategy

Determining the Optimal Breadth of your Product Portfolio

Due to technology changes and a stiffing competition at all levels, historically companies needed to constantly check their portfolio and cut off unpr...
Usage (application): Product Portfolio Analysis

Why Large Firms are Having Difficulties to Deal with Disruptive Innovations

Christensen explains why many firms, especially large firms, have trouble with adapting and thus with surviving when dealing with external disruptive ...
Usage (application): Innovation Management

The Role of Competitors in Strategy and Business Failures

Gilad (2014) researched in what way and to what extent competitors do matter. Many people believe that competitors are often the main source of busine...
Usage (application): Competitive Strategy, Competitive Environment, Competitive Intelligence, Industry Analysis

How BOP Countries Can Disrupt Western Markets

After the Second World War, Japan started to develop fast as a result of their disruptive innovation strategy. This disruptive innovation process init...
Usage (application): Disruptive Innovation, Bottom of the Pyramid, Country-level Strategy

Resources - Trajectories of Industry Change Premium

Scenario Planning and Risk Management in Uncertain Business Enviroment

Extensive and detailed presentation.
- Integrated Risk Management Framework
- Strategic Management Framework
- History of ...
Usage (application): Scenario Planning, Risk Management, Strategic Uncertainty

Vertical Dis-integration

By providing a theoretical framework that explains how and why vertical dis-integration happens, this inductive longitudinal analysis by Michael G. Ja...
Usage (application): Industry Change


Change Trajectories


Industry Change


Change Trajectories


Industry Change


Change Trajectories


Industry Change


Change Trajectories


Industry Change

Compare with McGahan's Four Trajectories of Industry Change: Disruptive Innovation  |  Forget Borrow Learn  |  BCG Matrix  |  Five Forces  |  Diamond Model  |  BPR  |  McKinsey Matrix  |  Core Competence  |  Profit Pools  |  Product Life Cycle  |  ADL Matrix  |  Bass Diffusion Model  |  SWOT Analysis  |  Benchmarking  |  Positioning

Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |   Marketing  |   Strategy  |  Supply Chain & Quality

More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Special Interest Group Leader

You here

About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us | Privacy | Terms of Service
Copyright 2017 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V14.1 - Last updated: 24-7-2017. All names tm by their owners.