How to Reach Consensus among Executives on the Strategy?

Strategic Alignment
Knowledge Center


Jaap de Jonge
Editor, Netherlands

How to Reach Consensus among Executives on the Strategy?

🔥NEW Achieving alignment and agreement among the top executives of a large corporation in respect of the strategic vision and strategy is obviously really important, but not easy. Especially at times when disruptive technological changes pose existential challenges to firms.
An article I recommend by Bernard Kümmerli et all explains the process used by Swisscom for the above really well.

The process implemented at Swiscom to achieve leadership alignment around the long-term vision and strategy had the following steps:
  1. ESTABLISH COMMON GROUND. First, a foundation has to be laid to enable a fruitful discussion. An agreement has to be reached about common definitions and assumptions around 3 questions:
    • What business are we in? That might be a different one than the traditional or current business we are in today...
    • What is our innovation typology? Create a shared language, defining terms like core innovations, adjacent innovations, transformative innovations. And placing growth opportunities in these categories while assessing market size, acquisition candidates and competitors.
    • What is our growth gap? Determine the variance between the revenue and profit ambitions and what the existing company would achieve, assuming no major change. The authors make a case to visualize the gap in a dynamic way, showing the gap and how any strategic options that are chosen might affect it.
  2. EXPOSE MISALIGNMENTS. Avoid biases like Groupthink, Spiral of Silence and Abilene Paradox by bringing any disagreement in the open though structured discussions aimed at revealing the reasons behind the differences of opinion. Techniques used to achieve this were E-Surveys about aspiration levels, potential of opportunities, technology impacts, and differentiation capabilities of the firm. The surveys were held among the participants preceding the actual discussions. Next, participants were sorted into 2 groups: optimists and pessimists, adding some relief and humor to the disagreements.
  3. GET PHYSICAL. By deploying 2 active exercises, the executives were stimulated to move towards real, deep, alignment:
    • Walking the line. A physical representation was made of the disagreements on the floor and executives were then placed on this. Next, they were asked to try and convince each other to move towards their position.
    • Casting your vote. Each member was given 100 Swiss Francs to distribute into containers labeled with the main strategic options.
  4. SET OUT THE PATH FORWARD. This plan had 4 major elements:
    • A compelling story.
    • An accountable governance body (a venture decision board).
    • A separate management team for the new growth ventures.
    • Special metrics (like customer centricity and business agility) and incentives.
Compare also: Forget Borrow Learn | Stage-Gate | Disruptive Innovation.

Source: Bernard C. Kümmerli, Scott D. Anthony and Markus Messerer, "Unite your senior team - How Swisscom's leaders aligned around a growth strategy", HBR Nov-Dec 2018, pp. 60-69

⇒ Please react and share your experiences / recommendations on how to achieve strategic agreement among top executives… Thank you.


Josephat Olwal Ngesah

How to Reach Agreement Among Executives on Strategy

Interesting subject. People don't always agree on anything. Our different backgrounds, culture and b... Sign up

Paramathmuni srinivas Kumar

Unification of Intent Among the Concerned Executives

Top executives might benefit from counseling in order to create an intent to resolve the differences... Sign up

Charles Alter
Consultant, United States

Creating Executive Alignment on Purpose, Values and Strategy

I think there's too much emphasis on everyone agreeing on anything in most organizations. The bigger... Sign up

Maurice Hogarth
Consultant, United Kingdom

How to Manage Consensus Among Executives

CLARIFYING THE BUSINESS WE ARE IN (e.g. are we in letter delivery or promise / trust keeping?) e... Sign up

Ioannis Stathakopoulos
Manager, Greece

Aligning Executives on Strategy is a Real Challenge

Getting consensus will be easier if the organisation has a well accepted and followed vision and val... Sign up

Victor Chewe
Business Consultant, South Africa

The Foundation to Help Executives Reach Consensus on Strategy

My contribution is that the foundation to getting executives to reach consensus on strategy should h... Sign up

Akintunde Olusegun
Consultant, Nigeria

Aligning Strategic Vision, Purpose and Values Among the Executives

Strategic resources, values and purpose must all align with the corporate vision and, this must be a... Sign up

Charles Alter
Consultant, United States

Exposing Misalignments in Leadership team

Interesting discussion everyone. I recently read an HBR article that specifically addresses this iss... Sign up

Maurice Hogarth
Consultant, United Kingdom

Metamapping Misalignment & Consensus

@Charles Alter: Charles I have used the same approach with Metaplan (I use the name MetaMap as the p... Sign up


More on Strategic Alignment:
DIscussion Topics
👀How to Reach Consensus among Executives on the Strategy?
Aligning Project Management with the Business Strategy
Practical Implementation of IT Strategy
Integrated Business and IT Strategy and Execution
New Role? Chief Marketing Technologist
Strategic Alignment is Important
Business and IT Governance Model
A Multidisciplinary Approach to Strategic Alignment
Can Formula 1 Be Considered a Craft Industry?
Principles for Aligning IT with Corporate Strategy
How is Strategic Alignment Managed?
Apply Cynefin Framework for IT Strategy
Special Interest Group

Do you know a lot about Strategic Alignment? Become our SIG Leader

Strategic Alignment
Knowledge Center

About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2023 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V16.0 - Last updated: 28-1-2023. All names ™ of their owners.