Disadvantages of Vendor Rating; Where it is Difficult to Use

Vendor Rating
Knowledge Center


Next Topic

Vendor Rating > Forum > Disadvantages of Vendor Rating; Where it is Difficult to Use

Disadvantages of Vendor Rating; Where it is Difficult to Use
When limited sourcing (very few or only 1 supplier) is available, the use of the vendor rating is counter productive.

Limited number of vendors
Armin Gruening, Engineering & IT Manager, Australia, Member
Agreed - or if not counterproductive, at least of very limited benefit

Vendor Rating
AMARNATH YADAV, Student (University), India, Member
Agreed, but do the vendor rating for breaking monopoly and try to develop a new vendor if possible.

Vendor Rating in case of Limited Number of Suppliers
SANJEEV TIWARI, Business Consultant, India, Member
If there are limited suppliers, vendor rating can still be important to understand:
1. The supply effectiveness, and
2. The need to develop vendors (either the existing ones or new); it forms the basis for initiating vendor development.
Turning a blind eye to a problem will just keep it under the carpet.

Single Vendor? Do Vendor Assessment; not Vendor Rating
ANUJ KUMAR SHRIVASTAVA, Manager, India, Premium Member
In the situation when you have a single vendor, there is no point in doing vendor rating, as you have nobody to compete with the vendor.
The best thing you can do here is vendor assessment.
Compare him to the standards you expect him to deliver to you.
For example say his overall Performance is 80%, but On Time factor is just 50%. Then push him to make him understand and improve that.
Try to understand where the fault is and then bring change in policies if necessary.
Meanwhile search for new vendors and develop them. As you develop more, then you can rate them and keep not more than 2 assured vendors for long term business. As you mentioned they are rare or few.


Read all responses and join this discussion yourself.
Support your career and personal development with 12manage, the management platform.

    Log in

Special Interest Group Leader

Interested? Sign up for free.

Vendor Rating
Best Practices

Vendor Rating
Knowledge Center


Next Topic

About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
2019 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.2 - Last updated: 15-11-2019. All names of their owners.