Stuck in the Middle?

Competitive Advantage
Knowledge Center

Best Practices
Dave Coley, USA

Stuck in the Middle?

Why is getting stuck in the middle (=mixing the 3 types of competitive advantage) so problematic? Could an intelligent mix of these 3 be preferable?

  Gary Hawkins, UK
 

Mixed strategy = unprofitable

If a firm does not dedicate itself to one of the 3 strategies by Porter, it will almost certainly suffer from poor profitability. Why? Because it will lose both the (many) customers who demand the lowest possible prices and the (fewer but very profitable) customers who are prepared to pay a premium price for the best offering in the market. Furthermore, the corporate structure, culture, reputation, marketing efforts, motivation systems, etc of firms with a mixed strategy are likely to be unfocused and ineffective.

  Magnus, Sweden
 

Multiple business units

Porter mentioned that is is possible that firms create multiple seperate business units and can then realize multiple strategies.

  Jane, USA
 

Three-circle analysis

As it happens I am just reading an interesting short article in the HBR (Nov 2007) from professors Urbany and Davis on c...

  David, New Zealand
 

Stuck in the middle is not so bad

From experience I think that practically 'stuck in the middle' is not nearly as bad in reality as it may seem from a sch...

  C J Jacobs, Netherlands
 

Stuck in the middle and environment

A common theme of current strategic thinking is the relationship between an organisationís resources and capabilities as...

  Jaap de Jonge
Editor, Netherlands
 

Porter on Stuck in the Middle

In Competitive Advantage (p 17) Porter says: "A firm that is stuck in the middle will earn attractive profits only if th...

  Fereidoon
Student (MBA), Iran
 

Comment

Don't forget trade-off because of them you can't be better than who specially active in one of those fields... With mix ...

  Adeola Olisawo
Student (University), United Kingdom
 

Could 'Stuck in the Middle' Be Applied to Service Industry?

I found the 'stuck in the middle' discussion interesting and I am trying to learn something from your comments... But co...

 

More on Competitive Advantage:
Summary
Forum
Life Cycle Approach to Competitive Advantage
Focus your Efforts in Building Competitive Advantage
Competitive Advantage in Tough Times
🔥Is Superior Value to Customers a Competitive Advantage?
Knowledge Management is more important than CA
Why are Firms Different? Why Successful Firms Differ?
Cost and Value in Analysis of Competitive Advantage: 2 Sides of the Same Coin?
Successful Companies: Only Three Rules Needed?
The Role of AI in Competitive Advantage
Best Practices
Quotes Competitive Advantage
10 Routes to Competitive Advantage
Case studies in "Cost Leadership"
👀Stuck in the Middle?
How Can Logistics Help to Achieve a Competitive Advantage?
Changing from a Cost Leadership Strategy Into Differentiation
Competition versus Cooperation
Competitive Advantage or Die?
What is Competitive Advantage?
Competitive Advantage in a Monopolistic Market?
Health/Fitness Club Industry Analysis
What are the Risks of a Differentiation Strategy?
Weaknesses of Porter's Three Basic Types of Competitive Advantage
4 Stages of Hypercompetition
Special Interest Group

Do you have a keen interest in Competitive Advantage? Become our SIG Leader

Competitive Advantage
Knowledge Center



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2022 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.8 - Last updated: 17-8-2022. All names ô of their owners.