Shortfall in the PMBOK Framework

12manage is looking for
MBA students.

PMBOK > Forum Log in

Shortfall in the PMBOK Framework
I believe there is a major shortfall in this framework - the lack of the concept of Governance, which might be an addendum to the 'control' lozenge. Most PMs success is measured on delivering projects to time cost and quality, delivery though is the key differentiating factor. A project may be delivering perfectly to TC&Q, but if external business environmental factors have shifted, and the project is no longer viable to deliver the product that then delivers the benefit needed, the project manager now has a conflict of interest... I believe you need governance that ultimately owns projects or programmes, that remove the PM conflict of interest. It is the Governance that can decide to shut down a project, because it can no longer meet the original benefits case.

Response to Charlie Uk
Don't agree. There is no conflict of interest. The project Board makes that decision whether a project should continue to completion or not, not the P...Sign up

Response to Shortfall in the PMBOK Framework
Partial agree with Andrew, there is no say on project go or no go. In fact PM should give advices in the PM lifecycle and own the project who also nee...Sign up

About Governance in PMBOK
Ravindra K
In the third edition of PMBOK Governance is mentioned. It says at the beginning stage as well as in the risk management knowledge area that internal a...Sign up

Governance above Project Management level
Projects are vehicles to achieve certain outcomes as specified and scheduled.the entity which ordered the project is responsible to arrange with the p...Sign up

Governance in PMBOK Framework
Jean-Michel DE JAEGER, EMBA, PMP, Project Manager, France, Moderator
The PMBOK framework is a mono-project framework and the Project Manager has to follow the project objectives TCQ assigned to his project. They are par...Sign up

Response to Andrew
My point is there is no governance... thats the point. Without governance there is a conflict of interest for the PM, where culturally the measure o...Sign up

Governance or Managing
Vito Madaio
Please, be careful with the meaning of "Governance". Often "Governance" is an empty word. Instead, the PMBOK suggests that the Project Managers manag...Sign up

Governance in the PMBOK
The PMBOK is only one of many books of good practices published by PMI. The standard for portfolio management and the standard for program m...Sign up


Special Interest Group Leader
Jean-Michel de Jaeger, EMBA, PMP
Management Consultant

Best Practices

Expert Tips


About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
2019 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.0 - Last updated: 21-1-2019. All names of their owners.