Checklist of Common Errors in Performance Appraisals

12manage is looking for contributors...

Performance Appraisals > Best Practices Premium

Checklist of Common Errors in Performance Appraisals
Martin Dale
I was asked to make a list of common mistakes by managers in performance appraisals.
G.T. Milkovich and J.M. Newman report the following ones (Compensation, 2002):
1. Halo Effect: a favorable rating for all job duties based on performance in one duty in which the employee is a 'saint'.
2. Central Tendency: rating all employees close to the midpoint of the scale (irrespective of their actual performance).
3. Recency Effect: judging overall effectiveness on the basis of recent experience.
Some others I found:
4. Subjectiveness: based on gut feeling
5. No/Poor Follow-up
6. Improper Preparation
Who can help me and provide further common mistakes or biases in employee appraisals? Thanks!

Performance Appraisal ErrorsSign up
Michel Lemieux
You could add
7. Lack of
Common Perfomance Management ErrorsSign up
Runyararo Chimwanda, Member
8. Cultural aspects prevent an objective rating...

Common Performance Appraisal MistakesSign up
9. Making appraisals too complicated is a c...

Performance Appraisal is a Big MistakeSign up
David McAra, Member
The biggest mistake is imagining that performance ...

Mistakes by Managers in AppraisalSign up
shaikh husnuddin nooruddin, Member
10. Not considering the period of service and e...

People are DifferentSign up
Mauro Piccone
11. Not being adaptive in the appraisal. Pe...

Common Mistakes in AppraisalsSign up
12. Use of a Gauss curve based on budget availa...

Common Errors in Performance AppraisalSign up
ATBA Bouchaib, Member
13. Overemphasizing negative aspects of the per...

Common Error Made Deliberately in Performance Appraisal.Sign up
14. Biasing deliberately towards employees ...

Performance Appraisal ErrorsSign up
Gerald Abeyawardena, Member
15. Leniency: giving higher marks than the ...

Importance of the PersonSign up
Joseph , Member
17. Treating employees as assets: employees...

Other Mistakes in Performance AppraisalSign up
Gana Cisse, Member
18. Projection Effect: when the appraiser p...

Frequent Performance Appraisal MistakesSign up
H P JANI, Member
21. Impatience: an appraisal must be follow...

Frequent Mistake by Managers in Appraising SurbordinatesSign up
Ngosa Mubanga
22. Wait for the final appraisal to point out e...

Frequent Performance Appraisal ErrorsSign up
Philip Oldfield, Member
23. Lack of effort and viewing the appraisal as...

Frequent Performance Appraisal ErrorsSign up
24. Lack of a Rational Technique to analyze...

Performance Appraisal Purpose and TargetsSign up
Marcel Wiedenbrugge, Member
26. Not clearly defining purpose and targets

Performance Appraisal ErrorsSign up
Jayaram, Member
27. Annual meeting only: performance appra...

Performance Appraisal Structure and Reward SystemSign up
Rev. Joseph Ubom
Organizations should create a more structured syst...

Frequent Performance Appraisal FlawsSign up
Fariborz, Member
29. Unqualified appraiser: since performanc...

Frequent Performance Appraisals FaultsSign up
Ray Hager, Member
30. (Un)pleasant surprises: nothing in a pe...

SMART Performance AppraisalsSign up
Nirmala Herrkaur Strange, Member
31. Objectives not SMART: discerning which ...

Common Performance Appraisal FallaciesSign up
mthembu, Member
32. Rigid appraisal formats: the appraisal ...

Problems with Perfomance AppraisalsSign up
The performance appraisal system is good in improv...

Performance Appraisals ProblemsSign up
Ismail Sahabodien, Member
34. Poor Identification of Objectives of Organi...

Performance Evaluation SystemSign up
Ahmed N. Qeshta
35. The performance evaluation system itself is...

Biases and Grudges During Appraisal TimeSign up
sujata, Member
36. Time to get even: a lot of supervisors ...

Strictness in Performance AppraisalSign up
Dodi Gunawan, Member
37. Strictness. This "strictness" is subjec...

Errors in Appraisals in Multinationals due to Cultural DifferencesSign up
Y.S.Ganesh, Member
In case of multinational companies:
38. La...


On 4. Performance Appraisal Being Too SubjectiveSign up
Simon Lum, Member
It is a "performance appraisal", therefore a big p...

The Main Mistake is Organizing AppraisalsSign up
Jozef Van Giel, Member
The most important mistake of performance appraisa...

Crucial Error in Performance ReviewsSign up
Jesu, Member
41. Not using the review for capacity building ...

Mistakes when Conducting Performance AppraisalsSign up
Zinnia Umana, Member
Another common mistake is
42. Not having s...

On 4. Use of Feelings Instead of Facts and TruthSign up
Mohammed Ishag Altaib, Member
I agree facts and the truth are the areas the eval...

On 23. Lack of effort to Prepare AppraisalSign up
In most cases, one does not even critically examin...


Performance Appraisal is an OpportunitySign up
Graham Blowers, Member
The PA is an opportunity to review the progression...

Problems in Performance AppraisalSign up
Sally Abdel Raouf, Member
43. Improper formulation of the appraisal form<...

Problem with Performance AppraisalsSign up
Charles P. Keith, Member
Most performance appraisals are based on an agreed...

Problems with Performance AppraisalsSign up
Nirmala Herrkaur Strange, Member
The emphasis is on agreed objectives/deliverables ...


Another Frequent Error in Performance AppraisalsSign up
asada raymond, Member
46. Appraisers often lack adequate knowledge of...

Using Performance Appraisal for Victimizing orSign up
47. Using Performance Appraisal to settle score...


On 23: DELIBERATELY Not Informing the Employee with Proper Expectations and MetricsSign up
Syed Arifulla MBA, PMP, Prince2, Premium Member
49. Managers deliberately do not...

Errors in Performance AppraisalsSign up
Mark Fuller, Member
50. Not measuring against the appraisee's previ...

Errors in Performance AppraisalsSign up
Yashashree Borges, Member
51. Business heads not taking performance appra...

Stop Appraisal InterviewsSign up
Jozef Van Giel, Member
@Paolo Pozzi: W...

On 4: Subjective AppraisalsSign up
Briolett, Member
In subjective...



2 More Mistakes to Avoid in Performance EvaluationSign up
Javier Elenes, Member
There are 2 more common BIG mistakes that you shou...


  Do you wish to study further? You can learn more from the summary, forum, discussions, lessons, courses, training, instructions, expert tips, best practices and education sources. Register.  

Special Interest Group Leader

You here

More on Performance Appraisals

Best Practices
Expert Tips


About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
2018 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V14.1 - Last updated: 22-7-2018. All names of their owners.