When are Misdeed Committers Accepted as Advisors?

Ethics and Responsibility


Anneke Zwart
Student (University), Netherlands

When are Misdeed Committers Accepted as Advisors?

People that made a severe mistake in the past sometimes feel the need to help others to avoid making these same mistakes. And indeed, one could say that people that have experienced the making of such a mistake themselves are in a way qualified to give good advices to other people.
In some cases the advices of misdeed committers are socially accepted. However, the advices of error-makers are often not accepted and disseminated. Rather, their words sometimes are met with charges of hypocrisy.

When is it socially acceptable to advice others based on your own errors? Conditions

Effron and Miller (2015) find that the likelihood that people will accept and listen to advice of someone who committed a misdeed increases if he/she is material suffering from his/her earlier misdeed. Examples of "MATERIALLY SUFFERING" are job losses, disease and losses of financial capital. What are the main causes for this?
  • RIGHT TO OFFER ADVICE: It was found that not accepting the advice of someone who has committed a misdeed does not always come from the fact that the wisdom of the misdeed committer is doubted. Rather, feelings of hypocrisy towards misdeed committers often results from the question whether the advisors have the right or legitimacy to offer such advices. Material suffering raises the perception that offering advice is legitimate and decreases the negative stands from advice-receivers. Besides, it also makes advice-givers more comfortable giving the advice.
  • COMPENSATING FOR INCONSISTENCIES: People do not like inconsistencies between what someone says and what he/she is doing (preaching). Suffering is in a way a punishment for failing to practice what someone is saying, and as such compensates for the inconsistency between words and deeds.
These are the 2 ways in which material suffering from misdeeds increases the likelihood that advice-receivers will accept the advice from those who committed a misdeed.
Source: Effron, D.A. and Miller, D.T. (2015) Do as I say, Not as Ive Done: Suffering for a Misdeed Reduces the Hypocrisy of Advising Others Against it Journal of Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes Vol. 131 pp. 16-32


Jaap de Jonge
Editor, Netherlands

Why we Accept Questionable Advisors

There could be at least two more reasons why explaining how you suffered for a misdeed which you com... Sign up


More on Ethics and Responsibility:
Methods, Models and Theories
Discussion Topics
Why do People / Organizations Act Ethically?
Professional Management Code: The MBA Oath
Female Managers are More Ethical
Consequentialist Theories in Business Ethics
Emerging of Ethics After a Chaotic State
Ethics Oath for Public Servants?
What if Superiors Have Different Ethics...
Doughnut Economics: 21st Century Economics
The Difference between Ethics and Values
Economics with Spiritualism and Ethical Businesses are Needed
Ethics and the Ego-ridden Individual
Why are Business People / Managers not Ethical?
Accountancy Ethics
Integrity in Business: Definition and Issues
Buying a Problematic Business
Ethics is Universal, Flavor is Regional
Organizational Justice
Ethical Business Requires a Long Time Horizon
Planned Obsolescence: Ethical or Not?
👀When are Misdeed Committers Accepted as Advisors?
Ethical Issues in Using Social Media Conversation Data for Business
Success Requires Responsibility
About 'De' (德), an Ancient Chinese Moral and Ethical Virtue
🔥Confidentiality - Importance and Ethics
Ethical Issues in Human Resources Management
Is the term 'Third World' Ethical?
Loyalty in Business and Ethics
Personal Ethics and Responsibility Must Come First
The Need for a Global Business Ethics
Ethics in Public Administration
Shan Zhai and the Trickster

Ethics and Responsibility

About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
2023 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V16.0 - Last updated: 1-2-2023. All names of their owners.