Mintzberg Critique on POSDCORB

Functions of Management (POSDCORB)
Knowledge Center

Forum

New Topic

Anneke Zwart
Student (University), Netherlands

Mintzberg Critique on POSDCORB

Just like Gulick, Mintzberg also studied the description of managerial functions and asked himself what managers really do. In his analysis, he critically reviewed the description of managerial functions according to Gulick and Urwick (1937), the POSDCORB. Mintzberg has the following criticisms on Gulick's POSDCORB:
1. According to Mintzberg, POSDCORB does not describe the actual managerial functions; rather it just specifies some vague objectives that managers seek to achieve.
2. Besides this, according to Mintzerg there are many managerial functions that do not fit into any of the POSDCORB categories. Thus, POSDCORB fails to explain certain jobs. Examples are networking and informal discussions by managers.
3. Finally, Mintzberg concludes that POSDCORB does not help to understand the concept of managerial work at all. Rather, it hinders the search for a deeper understanding of managerial functions.

Mintzberg suggests a more useful alternative that better describes the essential roles of managers and specifies 10 roles in 3 groups that managers can play:
1. Interpersonal role: The roles that are included in the interpersonal role are the figurehead role, the leader role and the liaison role.
2. Informational Role: The roles that are included in this group are the monitor role, the disseminator role and the spokesman role.
3. Decisional Role: The roles included here are the role of entrepreneur, disturbance handler, resource allocator or negotiator.
Because the 10 roles are overlapping and interdependent, a manager should learn how to balance them in order to become an efficient manager.
Sources: Mintzberg, H. (1980) “The nature of managerial work” Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Williams, B.B. (2010) “Incident Command as a Participative-Management Practice: Dispeling the Myth of Authoritarian Command. “International Fire Service Journal of Leadership and Management Vol. 4 Iss.1 pp. 9-21

Start a new forum topic

 

More on Functions of Management (POSDCORB)
Summary
Forum
Does Directing include Leadership?
Mintzberg Critique on POSDCORB
About Organizing as a Management Function
Changes in Management Functions in Modern Time
Add 8th Function of a Manager to POSDCORB: Communication
🔥How Managers can Boost Productivity
Planning as Quintessence
POSDCORB Assessment on School Management
The History of POSDCORB
About Budgeting in POSDCORB
Best Practices
10 Managerial Roles by Mintzberg
POSDCORB: The B of Budgeting is Important
Special Interest Group

Do you have a keen interest in Functions of Management (POSDCORB)? Sign up for free

Notify your students

Copy this into your study materials:

and add a hyperlink to:

Link to this discussion

Copy this HTML code to your web site:

Functions of Management (POSDCORB)
Knowledge Center



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2021 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.8 - Last updated: 25-7-2021. All names ™ of their owners.