|
Geoffrey Hill, US
|
Servant vs Charismatic Leaders
Are Servant-Leadership and Charismatic Leadership opposites?
X
Welcome to the Servant-Leadership best practices. The topic being discussed here is: "Servant vs Charismatic Leaders".
Please sign up now to read all responses and to join this discussion yourself.
Log in
| |
|
VMIX, USA
|
|
Servant leader and Charismatic leader
No! The servant as leader and a charismatic leader are not opposites. The Servant Leader has most characteristics of the 10 Robert Greenleaf traits described in the summary and just like the Charismatic Leader has a way about them that just makes you want to follow him. Like Gandi.
|
| |
|
Fentress Truxon
Management Consultant, United States
|
|
I Agree with VMIX
SL and CL are completely different like with this written example.
|
| |
|
Jagdish B Acharya
Consultant, India
|
|
Servant and Charismatic Leadership Objectives and Styles Compared
A servant leader has an objective of service for which he leads. A charismatic leader has a style by which he appears to lead naturally. Different followers will join depending on leader types. (Servant - S, Charismatic - C)
1. S AND C - Leader will have faster growth of followers due to C factor and sustenance due to S factor.
2. S AND NOT C - Leader will have sustained but slow growth. Like Christ.
3. C AND NOT S - Leader may get many followers, but only as imitators and may not ensure sustainance.
4. Not C AND NOT S - Leader has less chances of success as a leader. May mostly be follower of what he is interested in.
|
| |
|
Kovit Skulsangjuntr, Thailand
|
|
Servant Leadership Style Vs. Charismatic
Imagine going to the jungle and you have a hunter to guide you along the way. Or go with a tour group with a guide who g...
|
| |
|
bunny gaviyao
Investor, Zimbabwe
|
|
Comparing Servant Leadership and Charismatic Leadership
These two seem similar, but the difference is that a charismatic leader can be a dictator which is not found in servant ...
|
| |
|
scott kazee, United States
|
|
Servant Leader versus Charismatic Leader
I think the answer lies in our definition of what charismatic leadership. Christ was a charismatic leader! He was dynami...
|
| |
|
Dmytro Shynkaruk
Student (University), Ukraine
|
|
Servant Leadership versus Charismatic Leadership
These are totally different things. As it has already been mentioned, Hitler was a charismatic leader, Mussolini was a c...
|
| |
|
Andrea Kelly, Jamaica
|
|
Balanced Approach
I like Scott Kazee's remarks as people tend to desire to achieve what another person has but shy away from imitating as ...
|
| |
|
Michr
|
|
Servant versus Charismatic
Are servant and charismatic opposite styles of leadership?
- A servant leader may be charismatic in nature and in actio...
|
| |
|
Amirruddin Baba
Malaysia
|
|
Servant versus Charismatic Leaders
For me they are not opposites. They are qualities that compliment each other. Followers need security and feel secure wh...
|
| |
|
Arif ur Rehman
Professor, Pakistan
|
|
The Debate - Servant versus Charismatic Leaders
The servant leader is a savant in that he nurtures the spirit, helping all to be part of a concerned culture wherein sat...
|
|
|
|
|
More on Servant-Leadership:
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Log in