Effective Leadership by Switching Between Dominance and Prestige

Leadership Styles
Knowledge Center

Best Practices
Anneke Zwart
Student (University), Netherlands

Effective Leadership by Switching Between Dominance and Prestige

The leadership styles Dominance and Prestige are fundamental strategies used by (potential) leaders to find their ways through organizational hierarchies:
  • Leading through Dominance refers to the act of being assertive, leverage one's power/authority as a means to influence others. This type of leadership gives little room for followers to have a choice between following or not following the leader.
  • Leading through Prestige refers to a style in which wisdom and expertise, through being a role model, stimulate followers to follow. Instead of leading mainly through showing power, prestige allows others to be influential but they pull the strings from behind. This in turn means that leadership through prestige represents a more negotiable leadership style compared to dominance.
When asking the question what leadership style is best, the answer is that neither style is necessarily better than the other. Rather, it depends on the situation. Although it is not possible to point to one of the two leadership styles as being the best one, there are several competences that effective leaders must master:
- As philosopher Machiavelli wrote: "People are driven by two principal impulses, either by love or by fear". The best leaders are able to understand both concepts. In other words, an understanding of BOTH leadership styles is essential.
- The ability to ANALYZE the situation, DETERMINE what leadership style is most effective and then DEPLOY the most effective leadership style.
- Effective leadership also requires the ability to SWITCH BACK AND FORTH between dominance and prestige, depending on the culture of an organization and the tasks that need to be done. Being able to utilize both styles helps leaders to quickly adjust to different situations and cultures.
⇒ To what extent do you agree that this mix of dominance and prestige is needed to be an effective leader?
Source: Maner, J. (2016) "Good Bosses Switch Between Two Leadership Styles" Harvard Business Review

  Lupton-Bowers Pamela
Consultant, Switzerland
 

Direct and Democratic Leadership

I still like the oldie but goody Tannebaum Schmidt model of leadership styles from Autocratic to Democratic (or rather F...

  Dr. Alan Williams
Professor, Thailand
 

Switching Between Dominance and Prestige

Just one comment, I suggest the word Prestige should be replaced by the word Credibility. To my thinking Dominance sugg...

  Jaap de Jonge
Editor, Netherlands
 

Dominance as a Leadership Style

@Dr. Alan Williams: indeed the Dominance style is more or less forcing followers to follow. We should not change the ter...

  Dr. Alan Williams
Professor, Thailand
 

Switching Between Dominance and Prestige ⇒ Directive and Credibility

OK, so I still object to the 'title 'Dominant' and I would suggest: 'Directive' instead. In fact, in McClellands well-re...

 

More on Leadership Styles:
Summary
Forum
Authentic Leadership
Shaw about Situational Leaders
Leadership and Humilty
Leadership Style: born or made
Why is the Commanding Leadership Style Still Abundant?
The Best Leadership Style
What Causes the Choice for a Leadership Style?
How to Assess Your Own Leadership Style?
Leadership Styles are Labels
Reverse Determination of Leadership Style
Bad Leadership in Organizations
What Makes a Leader Effective or Not?
3 Kinds of Leaders: Builders, Maintainers and Destroyers
Creating Resonance versus Buy-in?
🔥From Military to Digital Leadership Styles
General Allenby (Field Marshal Viscount Allenby)
Democratic/Participative Leadership
Leadership by Setting an Example
Leadership by Using Psychology
Best Practices
Adjusting, Altering and Varying the Leadership Style
Visionary Leadership
Pitfalls and Drawbacks of Authentic Leadership
👀Effective Leadership by Switching Between Dominance and Prestige
What is the Preferred Leadership Style in Various Countries?
Special Interest Group

Do you have a keen interest in Leadership Styles? Become our SIG Leader

Leadership Styles
Knowledge Center



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
2022 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.8 - Last updated: 11-8-2022. All names of their owners.