Mayer's Ability Model of Emotional Intelligence. Comparison Goleman

Emotional Intelligence
Knowledge Center

Forum

New Topic

Anneke Zwart
Student (University), Netherlands

Mayer's Ability Model of Emotional Intelligence. Comparison Goleman

The Ability Model of Mayer of Emotional Intelligence (EI) versus Goleman.
Mayer has been the first who defined the concept of EI. After that, many contributors including Goleman have developed different definitions of EI and used different approaches to define and measure it. Because Mayer and Goleman have both been important contributors, it is interesting to see in what way their approches to EI are different.

1.The Competence-based Approach of Goleman: Although both theories/models do have overlaps, Goleman developed a different definition of EI that existed of the Four Domains of EI described in the summary. In short, these are:
1.1. Self-awareness
1.2. Self-management
1.3. Social awareness
1.4. Relationship management
These four clusters together form seventies EI competencies that are all categorized in one of the four domains.

2. The Ability model of Mayer: Mayer developed the so-called ability model of EI, in which EI exists of 4 cognitive abilities containing the ability to identify, explain and use emotions. The 4 cognitive abilities are:
2.1. Perceiving emotions
2.2. Integrating emotions so as to simplify thought
2.3. Comprehending emotions
2.4. Managing emotions.

Besides the obvious difference in domains, the 2 most important additional differences between the 2 models are the following:
1. Narrow definition: Mayer’s model was the first model describing EI. This might be the reason that the Ability Model of Mayer is far more narrow in its description of EI. The model only exist of four cognitive abilities, whereas Goleman’s includes seventeen EI-competencies.
2. Hierarchy: The ability model of Mayers is hierarchical constructed; each ability is dependent on the abilities below. For example, Managing emotions can only be effective if one is able to understand, integrate and perceive emotions. Goleman’s compentence-based approach is non-hierarchical.
Are there any more differences?

Source: Clark, N. (2010) “Emotional Intelligence and its Relationships with Team Processes” Team Performance Management Vol. Vol. 16 Iss.1/2 pp. 6-32

Participate and leave a comment
Exchanging your ideas stimulates your personal and professional development. And you can help other people! Please motivate your point of view. You can still edit your comment for 3 hours.

Start a new forum topic

 

More on Emotional Intelligence
Summary
Forum
The Importance of Soft Skills for Young People
🔥Ethical Emotional Intelligence?
3 Approaches Towards Emotional Intelligence
Emotional Intelligence is NOT Opposite of Intelligence
The 4 Domains and 12 Competencies of Emotional Intelligence
How you Should Manage Yourself (Drucker)
Best Compliment: 'You must have a high EQ'.
Emotional Intelligence - Better Predictor of Success then IQ
Emotional Intelligence of Groups and Companies
Some Level of EQ and IQ Either Way is Needed
Are these Responses Proof of Emotional Intelligence?
EI and Sensitivity for Subconscious Mind
Mayer's Ability Model of Emotional Intelligence. Comparison Goleman
Importance of Emotional Intelligence for Organisations
Understanding Emotions Logically
Best Practices
Intelligence of the Heart
(How) Can I improve my Emotional Intelligence?
Goleman's 3 Questions to Increase your Emotional Intelligence
The Benefits of Emotional Intelligence (EQ)
How to Moderate the Effect of Negative Moods on Your (Team's) Performance
Emotional Intelligence and Age
The Effects of Emotional Intelligence on Leadership
Soft Skills and Emotional Intelligence
The Role of Management in Developing EI and Soft Skills
Cross-cultural Validity of Emotional Intelligence
Emotional Intelligence versus IQ
Emotions versus Reason
EQ / EI Questionaire
Where does Wisdom come from?
Cleaning our Emotions
Emotional Intelligence = Maturity?
How can EQ and IQ be Combined?
Special Interest Group

Are you interested in Emotional Intelligence? Sign up for free

Notify your students

Copy this into your study materials:

and add a hyperlink to:

Link to this discussion

Copy this HTML code to your web site:

Emotional Intelligence
Knowledge Center



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2021 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.8 - Last updated: 8-5-2021. All names ™ of their owners.