Are Clayton Christensenís Disruptive Innovation Characteristics Useful in Practice?

Disruptive Innovation
Knowledge Center

Forum

New Topic

Rick Mueller
Professor, United States

Are Clayton Christensenís Disruptive Innovation Characteristics Useful in Practice?

A recent write up published in MIT Sloan Management Review concludes that Disruptive Innovation theory is "not very useful" for making predictions based on research in which 77 cases from Christensenís first two books (The Innovatorís Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution) were checked for four characteristics deemed to be fundamental to Disruptive Innovation:

  1. Incumbents improving along a trajectory of sustaining innovation.
  2. They overshoot customer needs.
  3. They possess the capability to respond to disruptive threats.
  4. They end up floundering as a result of the disruption.
Professor Andrew A. King and Baljir Baatartogtokh assert that only 7 of the cases contained all 4 of the elements of the theory. The majority of the 77 cases included different motivating forces (such as legacy costs, the effect of numerous competitors, changing economies of scale, and shifting social conditions) or displayed unpredicted outcomes.
Thoughts?
More information: Digital Journal

Start a new forum topic

 

More on Disruptive Innovation
Summary
Forum
Disruptive Change and HR
WHAT is Being Innovated? The 4 Ps of Innovation
Leadership and Taking Action
Timing is Important to Make an Innovative Idea Disruptive
Asymmetric Innovation
🔥Innovation Ideas in Economic Slowdowns
Business Model Innovation
DI or Improved Technology?
Slow Innovation: PROs, CONs and Tips
A DI Questions what we Don't Know
Blue/Innovate and Red/Disrupt
Comparison DI versus Blue Ocean Strategy
DI and Public Sector Organisations
DI: What Causes the Creative Leap?
Is Value Innovation DI?
Leadership Skills / Approaches for Successful Innovation
Paradigmatic Changes Require Re-orientation of Ones World Views
The Resources-Processes-Values (RPV) Framework
Are Clayton Christensenís Disruptive Innovation Characteristics Useful in Practice?
Better Input from Consumers Needed for DI
Leapfrogging Technologies by Developing Countries
The Word 'Disruptive' in DI
What is DI Exactly? Definition
Distinguishing Three Types of Innovation
Is DI Radical?
Breakthrough versus DI
Best Practices
Innovation Strategy: The Three Horizons of Growth (McKinsey)
Disruptive versus Incremental Innovation
DI: Product versus Platform
The Jobs to be Done Approach (JTBD) and DI
Strategic Options for Old-Technology Firms
Impact of the New Technology
Tips for Innovation Strategy
Typical Disruptive Technologies
How to Develop DI Skills?
Diversity of Perspective is Key to DI
How to Find Innovative Ideas? From Analogous Markets...
How to Sustain DI?
Is Cirque du Soleil the iPhone or the Seiko of Circus?
Ways to Incorporate DI as Part of the Management Agenda
The Hybrid Innovation Approach to Manage Technological Disruptions
Special Interest Group

Do you have a keen interest in Disruptive Innovation? Become our SIG Leader

Disruptive Innovation
Knowledge Center



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
© 2021 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.8 - Last updated: 4-8-2021. All names ô of their owners.