Are Clayton Christensenís Disruptive Innovation Characteristics Useful in Practice?
Rick Mueller, Professor, United States, SIG Leader
A recent write up published in MIT Sloan Management Review concludes that Disruptive Innovation theory is "not very useful" for making predictions based on research in which 77 cases from Christensenís first two books (The Innovatorís Dilemma and The Innovator's Solution) were checked for four characteristics deemed to be fundamental to Disruptive Innovation:
Professor Andrew A. King and Baljir Baatartogtokh assert that only 7 of the cases contained all 4 of the elements of the theory. The majority of the 77 cases included different motivating forces (such as legacy costs, the ef...
- Incumbents improving along a trajectory of sustaining innovation.
- They overshoot customer needs.
- They possess the capability to respond to disruptive threats.
- They end up floundering as a result of the disruption.