Advantages and Disadvantages of Portfolio Planning Tools

Strategic Portfolio Management
Knowledge Center

Forum

New Topic

Frank Bacchus
Management Consultant, United States

Advantages and Disadvantages of Portfolio Planning Tools

What are the pros and cons of portfolio planning tools like the BCG Matrix or the GE/McKinsey matrix?

  Sathya Devarakonda
Project Manager, India
 

Disadvantages of Portfolio Planning Tools

Sir, as far as I believe there are not necessarily disadvantage of any framework or a model. But a model or framework has assumptions and limitations like the time or the maturity of your products.
Take for example Proctor and Gamble, Unilever, Colgate Palmolive. These Fortune 500 companies have been into marketing for many years in every known country; and the same product (a shaving cream, toothpaste or soap) is sold by different names in different countries like India, Brazil, China, Germany not to mention US and UK. The world wakes up with these companies. They have established products which have huge revenues that don't die. So they call them Cash cows. Probably BCG must have classified one of these companies products' and then created the BCG Matrix. Their model will probably also fit well to analyze or articulate a strategy for a Biscuit manufacturing company in India. Parle Biscuits has a set of of established brands and some of their revenues cannot be killed. The Indian children know these brands as they grow up. So a VP strategy at this FMCG can also use the BCG Matrix to classify his products and use the word cash cow (for some of their biscuit brands that have sales, that never die).
Models like BCG Matrix are used at various companies to classify their products and analyze to on where they should invest or innovate. A GE/Mckinsey model may be used by some other set of the companies across the globe in various setting based on time and need. 11-7-2021

Start a new forum topic

 

More on Strategic Portfolio Management
Summary
Forum
The BCG Matrix and Synergy Effects
Advantages and Disadvantages of Portfolio Planning Tools
Application of BCG Matrix in Forestry
BCG in Emerging or Fragmented Markets
Use of BCG Matrix in India
BCG Matrix: not in All Cases
Cash Cows Should Fund Stars in BCG Matrix
🔥Modified BCG Matrix 2.0
Not useful for Competitive Analysis
Question Mark Strategies and Examples
BCG Matrix and Continous Evaluation
How to Calculate the Relative Market Share in BCG Matrix?
Cash Cow Strategies and Examples
BCG Matrix is Not Useful for a Start-up Having Only One Product
BCG Matrix: How to Research the Market Share and the Market Growth for each Business?
The BCG Categories are not always Stages
The Financing Assumption of the BCG Matrix
Differences Between BCG Matrix and Ansoff Matrix
Direction of Arrow between Cash Cow and Star Incorrect?
Best Practices
10% Limit in Market Growth in BCG Matrix
Example BCG Matrix: Coca Cola & Pepsi Cola
Lack of Question Marks?
How Do I Place my Products / Services in the BCG?
Why the Quadrants of BCG Matrix are Named as Star, Dog, Cow, Problem Child
BCG Matrix is useless!
BCG Matrix Dog Strategies and Examples
How to do BCG Plotting?
BCG Matrix: Can Dogs be More Lucrative than Cash Cows?
Distinction Between PLC and BCG Matrix?
BCG Matrix Star Strategies and Examples
Special Interest Group

Do you have a keen interest in Strategic Portfolio Management? Sign up for free

Notify your students

Copy this into your study materials:

and add a hyperlink to:

Link to this discussion

Copy this HTML code to your web site:

Strategic Portfolio Management
Knowledge Center



About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us / Cite us | Privacy | Suggestions | Terms of Service
2021 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V15.8 - Last updated: 27-7-2021. All names of their owners.