Charismatic Leadership
(Weber)

12manage reaches 100.000 members

The Tripartite Classification of Authority. Explanation of Charismatic Leadership of Weber and others. ('22)

What is Charismatic Leadership? Description

Charismatic Leadership is defined by Max Weber as "resting on devotion to the exceptional sanctity, heroism or exemplary character of an individual person, and of the normative patterns or order revealed or ordained by him". He defines Charisma as "a certain quality of an individual personality, by virtue of which he is set apart from ordinary men and treated as endowed with supernatural, superhuman, or at least specifically exceptional powers or qualities. These are such as are not accessible to the ordinary person, but are regarded as of divine origin or as exemplary, and on the basis of them the individual concerned is treated as a leader (...). How the quality in question would be ultimately judged from an ethical, aesthetic, or other such point of view is naturally indifferent for the purpose of definition".

Charismatic people have a remarkable ability to distill complex ideas into simple messages ("I have a dream"); they communicate by using symbols, analogies, metaphors and stories. Furthermore they relish risk and feel empty without it, they are great optimists, they are rebels who fight convention, and they may seem idiosyncratic.

Charismatic leaders are pictured as organizational heroes or magic leaders who have the social power basis to orchestrate turnarounds, launch new enterprises, inspire organizational renewal, and obtain extraordinary performance from organizational members. These leaders inspire trust, faith and belief in themselves. Of course none of this is a guarantee that the mission will be correct, ethical, or successful.
 

Origin of the Charismatic Leadership model. History

German Sociologist Max Weber distinguished back in the 1920's three ideal types of leadership, domination and authority:

1. Charismatic domination (familial and religious),
2. Feudal / Traditional domination (patriarchs, patrimonalism, feudalism), and
3. Bureaucratic / Legal domination (modern law and state, bureaucracy).

Robert House (1977) used four phrases to define charismatic leadership:

1. Dominant.
2. Strong desire to influence others.
3. Self-confident.
4. Strong sense of one’s own moral values.

Conger & Kanungo (1998) describe five behavioral attributes of Charismatic Leaders:

1. Vision and articulation.
2. Sensitivity to the environment.
3. Sensitivity to member needs.
4. Personal risk taking.
5. Performing unconventional behavior.

Most recently charisma is being characterized as theatrical (Gardner & Alvolio, 1998): charismatic leadership is an impression management process enacted theatrically in acts of framing, scripting, staging, and performing. Compare also: EPIC ADVISERS.

Usage of the Charismatic Leadership style. Applications

• In difficult times or circumstances, such as an urgent organizational turnaround. Compare: Crisis Management.
• Note that according to Weber, a charismatic leader does not have to be a positive force. Both Mahatma Gandhi and Adolf Hitler could be reasonably considered charismatic leaders. Compare: Servant-Leadership
• See Core Groups theory for some of the mechanisms behind charismatic leadership.

Steps in Charismatic Leadership approach. Process

Jay Conger (1989) proposed the following four-stage model of charismatic leadership:

1. Continual assessment of the environment and formulating a vision.
2. Communication of vision, using motivational and persuasive arguments.
3. Building trust and commitment. subordinates must desire and support the goals of the leader and this is likely to be accomplished by more than coercion; rather the leader builds trust in the leader and the viability of the goals; this is likely to be done through personal risk taking, unconventional expertise, and self-sacrifice.
4. Achieving the vision. Using Role modeling, empowerment, and unconventional tactics.

Strengths of Charismatic Leadership style. Benefits

• Results in relatively strong, unchallenged levels of obedience.
• Useful in difficult times or circumstances, such as an urgent organizational turnaround. Compare: Crisis Management.
• Effective. If the charismatic leader's vision is right, this leadership style can be extremely effective.
• Rhetorical ability. Compare: Framing.
• Energetic, inner clarity, visionary, unconventional, and exemplary.

Limitations of Charismatic Leadership style. Disadvantages

• Results in relatively strong, unchallenged levels of obedience. Tendency of gathering weak "yes-men" around him. Poor delegation.
• People possessing these skills and attributes are relatively rare.
• Tendency to narcissism. Loosing reality. Insensitive to others. Compare: Seven Signs Of Ethical Collapse
• Lack of accountability. Freedom from inner (moral) conflicts. The values of charismatic leaders are essential. If such leaders are well-intentioned towards others, they can elevate and transform an entire company. But if they are selfish or poor, they can create cults and effectively rape the minds of the followers.
• Unpredictable. Potentially dangerous.

Charismatic Leadership Special Interest Group

Visit the Special Interest Group

Charismatic Leadership Forum

Nocturnal - USA

Current Charismatic Leaders

"Who, at the present moment do you consider to be prominent charismatic leaders in the world today? Why?"

1

Alyson Emmins - Australia

Female Charisma / Charismatic Leadership

"I have recently been double-checking various inflections of the usage 'charisma' in business or, in fact, in the description of photographic emblems. It would seem from the limited range of examples provided across onelook.com in various dictionaries, that women cannot have charisma or display charismatic leadership."

0

Pulane - S.A.

Zuma: Charismatic Leader?

"Is president Zuma a charismatic leader or not?"

0

Melanie - Holland

Creating a Shared Vision by Listening

"According to recent research by James M. Kouzes and Barry Z. Posner, being forward-looking - envisioning new possibilities and creating a shared vision of the future is the attribute that most distinguishes leaders from non-leaders. When people are asked what they believe is required for a colleague and a leader, the number one answer for both is honesty. After this, only 27% of respondents selected being forward-looking as something important in a colleague, whereas 72% mention this as a requirement for a leader. The authors recommend that the best way to lead people in the future is to connect with them deeply in the present, listening very closely to others, appreciating their hopes, and attending to their needs. Source HBR Jan 2009, p. 20-21."

2

Danish Noor - USA

Effective Leadership

"Effective Leadership style is the integration of three factors: Charismatic -- style based on exceptional personality or behavior, Knowledge -- style based on distinctive knowledge, and Experiential -- style based on vast experience. An effective leader can only achieve big hairy audacious goals when (s)he gained skills in all three paradigms. However, these persons are available in extreme paucity and are therefore in great demand by efficient organizations."

-3

Comment on this Page

Charismatic Leadership Education & Events

Compare with Charismatic Leadership: EPIC ADVISERS  |  Seven Surprises  |  Leadership Styles  |  Hagberg Model of Personal Power  |  Leadership Continuum  |  Level 5 Leadership  |  Servant-Leadership  |  Path-Goal Theory  |  Theory X Theory Y  |  Bases of Social Power  |  Seven Habits  |  Results-Based Leadership  |  Situational Leadership  |  Ashridge Mission Model  |  Framing  |  Crisis Management

Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |  Communication & Skills  |  Ethics & Responsibility  |  Leadership

More Management Methods, Models and Theory