Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development

Knowledge Center

   

Building, developing and maintaining a pipeline of skilled, prepared leaders from within the company. Explanation of the Leadership Pipeline of Stephen Drotter, James Noel and Ram Charan. (2001)

Contents

  1. Summary
  2. Forum
  3. Best Practices
  4. Expert Tips
  5. Resources
  6. Print

Leadership Pipeline (Drotter, Noel, Charan)What is the Leadership Pipeline? Description

Sometimes hiring an executive from the outside can be the only available short term option. However Drotter, Noel and Charan argue that for the long term, management should build, develop and maintain a pipeline of skilled, prepared leaders from within the firm. Their Leadership Pipeline model helps to create such a funnel of future management talent by explaining what changes in time application, skills and work values are essential for making the transition from one leadership stage to the next. Also their model helps to understand the different demands of various management levels.
 

Origin of the Leadership Pipeline. History

The Leadership Pipeline idea was based on work originally done at General Electric in the 1970s by Walt Mahler, a HR consultant and teacher. Mahler set out to identify all the changes that were required to be successful at different leadership levels. He concluded that the most important change involved work values: what one believes is important in the new job. Mahler also developed the Crossroads Model, suggesting that there were specific leadership crossroads in every organization, each with its own specific requirements. Drotter was a student and later a friend of Mahler and refined and adjusted the crossroads model into the leadership pipeline model. Executive Development and Coaching Consultant James Noel and Top-level Succession Planning Consultant and Professor Ram Charan also contributed later.


6 Passages in the Leadership Pipeline. Stages

  1. From Managing Self to Managing Others. People enter this stage when they demonstrate they are skilled individual contributors and they have the ability to collaborate with others.
    • Change in Time Application: These people must learn how to reallocate their time so that not only their own assigned work is completed, but also they help others perform effectively.

    • Change of Skills: Shift from doing work to getting work done through others.

    • Change of Work Values: From valuing their individual work to valuing managerial work.

  2. From Managing Others to Managing Managers.
    • Change in Time Application: In this phase, managers must only manage. They need to divest themselves of individual tasks.

    • Change of Skills: The key skills they must master during this transition include selecting people to turn passage 1, assigning managerial and leadership work to them, measuring their progress as managers, and Coaching them.

    • Change of Work Values: Learn to hold first-line managers accountable for managerial work rather than technical work.

  3. From Managing Managers to Functional Manager.
    • Change in Time Application: Participating in business-team meetings and working with other functional managers. Creating a functional strategy that enables them to do something better than the competition. Develop a sustainable Competitive Advantage within their function.

    • Change of Skills: Develop new Communication Skills and being able to manage some areas that are unfamiliar. Learn to consider other functional needs and concerns. Teamwork with other functional managers and compete for resources based on business needs.

    • Change of Work Values: Adopt a broad, long-term perspective.

  4. From Functional Manager to Business Manager.
    • Change in Time Application: Allocating time to think is a major requirement at this level: Managers need to stop doing something every second of the day and reserve time to reflect and analyze.

    • Change of Skills: Business managers are responsible for the bottom line. Rather than consider the feasibility of an activity, a business manager must examine it from a short- and long-term profit perspective.

    • Change of Work Values: Value the success of their own business.

  5. From Business Manager to Group Manager.
    • Change in Time Application: From running their own business to succeeding indirectly by managing and developing several businesses and business managers.

    • Change of Skills: Be able to:

      • Evaluate strategy in order to allocate and deploy capital.

      • Develop business managers.

      • Develop and implement a Portfolio Strategy.

      • Assess whether businesses have the right core capabilities to win.

    • Change of Work Values: Derive satisfaction from the success of other people’s businesses. Appreciate managing a portfolio of business.

  6. From Group Manager to Enterprise Manager.
    • Change in Time Application: Set direction and develop operating mechanisms to know and drive quarter-by-quarter performance that is in tune with longer term strategy. A subtle shift from strategic to visionary thinking, and from an operating to a global perspective. Let go of the pieces, and focus on the Whole. Assemble a team of high-achieving, ambitious direct reports, knowing that some of them want his job.

    • Change of Skills: Ability to manage a long list of external constituencies proactively.

    • Change of Work Values: Learn to value Trade-offs. Appreciate managing one entity.

Strengths of the Leadership Pipeline. Benefits

  • Helps to understand that management and leadership roles are not the same on all levels of an organization, because of many differences in optimal time application, skills and work values.
  • Dynamic model. Facilitates individual performance improvement, Coaching, Mentoring, training and experience assessments and planning.
  • Facilitates succession planning, leadership development. Helps to identify and prevent potential pipeline failures.
  • Improves selection processes.
  • Facilitates more objective promotion decisions.
  • Helps HR to focus on specific skills, time application and work values, rather than rely on generalized training and development programs.
  • Diagnostic tool to identify and remedy mismatches between individuals’ capabilities and their leadership level.
  • Timing. The pipeline provides a system for identifying when someone is ready to move to the next leadership level.
  • Efficiency. Little or no time is wasted on jobs that merely duplicate skills.

Limitations of the Leadership Pipeline. Disadvantages

  • Aimed at large organizations. Can however be used in medium-sized businesses as well, by removing the group management level and understanding that the business manager is also doing the work of the enterprise manager.
  • It takes a long time and sustained commitment to implement the framework.
  • As with any model, try to avoid a too mechanical implementation of the concept. Think holistically and with complexity of people and organizations in mind.

Book: Ram Charan, Stephen Drotter and James Noel - The Leadership Pipeline - How to Build the Leadership-powered Company -


Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development Forum
  Required Changes in Order to Implement Effective Leadership Development Programs
Godtfredsen (2014) observed that the organisations invest today far too little in developing leadership behaviours of its employees, they invest in too few individuals and the results of the implemented programs are far too ineffective compared to ho...
     
 
  Norburn's Match of Company Directors to GOGOs, YOYOs and DODOs
In an article Norburn (1986) tries to categorize directors of Britain’s largest companies and to find a connection with the economic performance of the industries their companies operate in:
- GOGO’s – industries in growth,
- YOYO’s – indus...
     
 
  How Superbosses Develop Future Leaders
Beyond building mighty companies, great leaders groom their managers to become in turn future successful leaders. That is according to Sydney Finkelstein (2016), who argues that what sets great leaders apart is a range of personality traits - such as...
     
 
  Leadership Best Practices in Family Businesses
Fernández-Aráoz, Iqbal and Ritter (2015) conducted research among 50 leading family-owned or family-controlled companies to find best leadership practices in family businesses:
  1. DEVELOPING A GOOD-GOVERNANCE BASELINE: Naturally, gov...
     
 
  How to Develop Leadership Competencies?
A lot of books and articles by various authors have been written about certain competencies being essential for effective leadership. Less is written about how organizations can actually develop these competencies.
My question is: how can critic...
     
 
  Executive Assessments Using Simulations
The success of a company depends on its top managers and executives. Decisions regarding engagements, staffing and positioning in this domain have extensive consequences and strategic impact.
Business projects like the introduction of a new prod...
     
 
  Examples of Succession Planning
Looking at the comments on succession planning (SP) there is agreement on the need for it.
I am looking for some examples of SP. Does anyone know a successful example or case?...
     
 
  Succession Planning for the CEO
Companies need to have a succession plan for governance, to retain talents, to grow their business. Especially for the CEO. This is a most important issue; it is a going concern for the company.
So it should be considered into the policies when ...
     
 
  Succession Planning in Government Organizations
Few events in the life of an association are as critical, visible, or stressful as when the leader leaves. The eyes of every member, employee, customer, supplier, and stakeholder are focused on the outgoing executive director or CEO. How such an exit...
     
 
  Indentify Competencies First
I find the leadership pipeline a useful model to identify the leadership and management competences required at the respective levels.
I am trying to identify firstly the overall leadership and management competencies required, along with...
     
 
  Leadership Pipeline is Aimed at Continuity
Though I appreciate that a leadership pipeline creates continuity in an organisation's management practice, I think new personnel engagement at different levels helps to inject some dynamism in an organisation through new idea's creatio...
     
 
  Leadership or Management Pipeline?
This appears to be a very helpful model for understanding management roles and planning management development. However, it also seems to be something of a misnomer as there is a clear difference between management and leadership. Leadership is about...
     
 
  Also Usable as System of Progression
A very comprehensive framework which ties in neatly with the situational leadership concept. Can be used as a framework for designing a 'Scheme of Service' and System of Progression and Milestones in companies and organizations. Certainly a ha...
     
 
  Using Co-creation for Leadership Pipelining
I am sure leadership pipeline can be best worked on in an organisation which has an institutionalized co-creation process.
The HR function, senior management including the CXO and board must make s...
     
 
  Wanting to Run Before I Could Walk
If you achieve each component of each pipe line passage stage systematically, you effect a response in other managers that enables you to move to the next management level. However if you are allowed or encouraged to jump to different management l...
     
 
  Leadership Pipeline vs Stratified Systems Theory
Has anyone done a scientific comparison between the two theories or tried to combined the 2 models? I would really be interested in seeing the results of such studies....
     
 
  Potential Assessment
For an employee to move from one passage to another, both, performance and potential needs to be sceintifically evaluated. Any tips on evaluating the Potential ?...
     
 
  Implementing the Pipeline
In implementing a Leadership Pipeline I found that line management is very slow in taking up the challenge. Is that common or am I imagining it?...
     
 
  Leadership Pipeline Model Accentuates Vertical Growth
A disadvantage of this model whilst using it in front of employees is that it accentuates vertical growth of individuals as the only careerpath. Careerpaths can be, on the one hand, more complex and less linear upwards (eg doing various jobs)....
     
 

Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development Special Interest Group


Special Interest Group

Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development Education & Events


Find Trainings, Seminars and Events


Best Practices - Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development Premium

Expert Tips - Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development Premium
 

How to Develop a Talent Factory

In an article "Make Your Company a Talent Factory" (HBR June 2007), Douglas A. Ready and Jay A. Conger make some useful complementory suggestions abou...
Usage (application): How to Implement a Leadership Pipeline, Best Practices
 
 
 

Myths on REACHING the top

I'd like to contribute a summary of an article by HRM Professor Monik...
Usage (application): What Experiences, Qualifications and Characteristics are Needed to Reach the Top?
 
 
 

Categeories of CEO's

In their book "The Secrets of CEOs", Steve Tappin and Andrew Cave identified that top-quartile CEOs fall into five distinct categories of leadershi...
Usage (application): Leadership Styles, CEO Types
 
 
 

Developing your Leadership Pipeline

In the HBR article "Developing your Leadership Pipeline Dec 2003" Jay A. Conger and Robert M. Fulmer considered 4 guidelines for building your leaders...
Usage (application): Implemention Guidelines and Best Practices
 
 
 

Five Leadership Development Ideas

Although years of research and analysis by biographers, historians, and scholars have produced an enormous library of books on leadership, Robert J. A...
Usage (application): Leadership Development, Management Development, Coaching, Mentoring
 
 
 

Identify and Develop Leadership Abilities

Four Rules of Leadership...  
 
 

Leadership Best Practices

- The best leaders always know how to involve others in making decisions: You will get a better range of ideas and they will feel more commi...
Usage (application): Leadership Development, Leadership Tips
 
 
 

Leadership Development Strategies

According to Robert M. Fulmer, Stephen A. Stumpf and Jared Bleak in the article “The Strategic Development of High Potential Leaders” (Strategy & Lead...
Usage (application): How to Develop Succesful Leadership Development Programs
 
 
 

How to Develop your Own Leadership Philosophy

In an article “When should a leader be directive or empowering? How to develop your own situational theory of leadership”, the best way to develop you...
Usage (application): Leadership/Management Development, Coaching, Mentoring
 
 
 

Recognizing Distressed Managers in Leadership Pipeline Transition

Moving from one manager level/phase to the following is a difficult task. Freedman (2011) describes the typical responses of distressed managers (DMs)...
Usage (application): Coaching, Mentoring, Management Development, Leadership Development
 
 
 

CSFs for 2nd Generation Succession

Often small businesses are transferred from one generation to another. This may continue for several generations. The process of succession can last f...
Usage (application): Small Business Transfers
 
 
 

Guiding High Potentials

According to Ram Charan in Harvard Management Update Jan 2008 Vol 13 #1, the most effective way to move a high potential along is to focus and give pr...
Usage (application): Leadership Development
 
 
 

Top-3 Pitfalls in Talent Management: Common Mistakes by Talent Managers

In companies talent management failures are made at various levels, from strategic failures to process and management failures. One of the most troubl...
Usage (application): Talent Management, Management Pipeline, Leadership Pipeline, Management Development, Management Succession Planning
 
 

Resources - Leadership Pipeline | Succession Planning | Leadership Development Premium

5 Ways to Develop your Leadership Skills

Obviously we all know that the best way to continuously develop your leadership skills is through 12manage ☺. Learn 5 more ways to become a bett...
Usage (application): Career Management, Career Planning, Management Development, Talent Management, Succession Planning
 

Learning Agility and Enterprise Agility

This presentation provides insights into the usage of organizational agility in your organization. The presentation includes the following sections: Usage (application): Organizational Agility
 

Mintzberg: 7 Myths on Management

In this interesting interview Prof. Henry Mintzberg refutes 7 myths on leadership and management:
  1. ORCHESTRA CONDUCTOR: One myth about man...
    Usage (application): Management Development, Leadership Development, Managers versus Leaders, MBA
 

Effective Change Leadership and Management: Principles, Frameworks and Tools

Comprehensive presentation on leadership and management in a change context.
1. Introduction and Overview
2. What is the difference between ...
Usage (application): Change Management, Change Leadership
 

Talent, Career and Succession Management and Management Development

Presentation about talent/career management and development including a lot of schemes which clarify each particular section. The following sections a...
Usage (application): Career Management, Career Planning, Management Development, Talent Management, Succession Planning
 

Succession Planning in Family Businesses

Presentation that elaborates on the main steps in Succession Planning with a focus on Family Businesses, including the following sections:
1. Wha...
Usage (application): Management Succession Planning
 

CEO Succession Planning

Presentation about CEO Succession Planning thereby making a difference between compliance-based and operational succession planning. The presentation ...
Usage (application): Succession Planning
 

How to Build a Global Organizational Capability?

A. How to build a global leadership group in which people can cope with the complexity of working globally?
1. Recruit people for le...
Usage (application): MNCs, Multinationals, Multinational Companies, Globalization, International Leadership Development, Cultural Intelligenc
 

From Traditonal to Advanced Talent Management

In-depth presentation about talent management. The following sections are included:
1. Talent Management and Globalization
1.0 Definition of...
Usage (application): Talent Management, Talent Planning, Talent Acquisition, Talent Retention, Talent Development, Career Planning, Successio
 

Leading versus Managing

Dr. John Kotter gives his opinion on what are the key differences between leading and managing.
- Management is a set of processes like planning,...
Usage (application): Understanding the differences between Leading and managing
 

Leadership Pipeline Diagram

Download and edit this 12manage PowerPoint graphic for limited personal, educational and business use. Republishing in intranets, websites, books, ma...
Usage (application): Succession Management
 
 

News

Leadership Succession
     
 

News

Succession Planning
     
 

Videos

Leadership Succession
     
 

Videos

Succession Planning
     
 

Presentations

Leadership Succession
     
 

Presentations

Succession Planning
     
 

More

Leadership Succession
     
 

More

Succession Planning
     

Compare with the Leadership Pipeline: Coaching  |  Mentoring  |  Cultural Dimensions  |  Cultural Intelligence  |  Contingency Theory  |  Situational Leadership  |  Leadership Styles  |  4 Dimensions of Relational Work  |  Spiral Dynamics  |  Seven Habits  |  Seven Surprises  |  Johari Window  |  EPIC ADVISERS  |  Level 5 Leadership  |  Hagberg Model of Personal Power


Return to Management Hub: Change & Organization  |  Communication & Skills  |  Human Resources  |  Leadership


More Management Methods, Models and Theory

Special Interest Group Leader

You here


About 12manage | Advertising | Link to us | Privacy | Terms of Service
Copyright 2016 12manage - The Executive Fast Track. V14.0 - Last updated: 25-8-2016. All names tm by their owners.